My top 10 P4P Fighters

Criteria based on:

- 40% ability/skill
- 20% Physical attributes/toughness
- 20% Wins/competative losses over elite competition
- 10% multi-weight capabilities/success
- 10% adaptability/stylistic range


1. Ray Robinson
2. Muhammed Ali
3. Pernell Whitaker
4. Roy Jones Jr
5. Ray Leonard
6. Marvin Hagler
7. Salvador Sanchez
8. Manny Pacquiao
9. Thomas Hearns
10. Floyd Mayweather Jr

 

Ability and opponents beat and you've got Floyd but no Chavez?

 

well observed

 

lol @ Ali being there.

 

Interesting, a bit too modern though. No? SRL and Hearns but no Duran?

 

Oh god, Mayweather?

 

Considering he's above Whitaker it doesn't seem that ridiculous.

 

i like that you included very specific criteria but even by that there are some odd ommissions/inclusions

 

**** all that, he SHOULD be there

 

Oh yes, what with his lack of multi-weight success as opposed to fighters like Armstrong and Robinson.

 

He would never include Duran no matter what!

 

Floyd but no B-Hop??!?!

 

i'm just glad the man doesn't see the need to penalize the man for being born a big cat. if ali were so inclined he could have gone down to middle and won every title on the way up:hey

 

have to be honest though, at various times i've had whitaker, jones, sanchez and hagler on my lists as well

 

Mayweather is not above Duran.