I would have abraham, gamboa and donaire a few places higher. And guzman would be about 5 places lower on my lw rankings.
No Paul Williams at 154 lbs.? Paulie Malignaggi may be top 10 at 140 lbs., but not top 5. Nonito Donaire should be ranked a lot higher. Donaire should be ranked #1 at 115 lbs. Andre Ward and Arthur Abraham should be ranked higher than Lucian Bute at Super Middleweight.
Abraham has one win at SMW; against Taylor (1-1 at the weight) and he should be in the top 2? I can't see that. Ward-Bute is pretty much even, and their next fights will be very important.
Abraham has 2 wins at super middle but i agree he should be lower than froch, bute and ward. personally i think Froch is number 1 at super middle. his resume is better than Bute, Ward or any of the other guys, and when it comes to common opponents, he comes out on top (Taylor, Tatevosyon)
Froch is right up there aswell. I have made a case for that ranking in the thread with the votes for your ESB rankings for #1 supermiddle, but if Froch beats Kessler he will naturally be #1 or #2. Ahead of Ward for sure, as he has Green next up. The good thing is, it will all be settled shortly.
think frochs style makes him under estimated by many. the fact is nobody had beaten him. and anyone that scored the fight for Dirrell needs a lesson in scoring a fight.
I have edited it now. Some things i agree with, some i don't, but i have corrected a number of my mistakes. The SMW rankings i am sticking with though. That's the way i see it and i have made my case for it in other threads.