After Money beats Mosley, Pacquiao and let's say Berto is he top 3 all time great?

I don't have Manny in the top10 right now.

Its crazy how every Floyd thread becomes about Pacquiao

 

Hell No.

 

Give me a top 30 option and i shall check that box. But to go from top 3 to top 10 to not in the top 50 is quite a slide.

 

Mosley, Pac then Pavlik then i say top 10. I think Floyd could have a decent chance vs Pavlik, granted he won't be Favorite.

 

hate it or not but i have Pernell in my top 5. Old time fighters are usually overrated a little on rankings imo. Srl will probably crack top 3 in 20-30yrs also on most peoples lists.

 

Well, lets look at his resume.

86-8 Amateur Record
1996 Olympic Bronze Medalist

43-0 Professional record
Titles at: 130, 135, 140, 147, 154
Lineal Titles at 130, 135, 147, and arguably 154
Wins Over:
Gernaro Hernandez(HOF)
Shane Mosley(HOF)
Oscar De La Hoya(HOF?)
Manny Pacquiao(HOF)
Ricky Hatton(HOF?)
Diego Corrales
Juan Manuel Marquez
Jose Luis Castillo
Arturo Gatti
Andre Berto
Jesus Chavez
Angel Manfredy
Phillip N'dou
Demarcus Corley
Carlos Baldomir
Zab Judah
Victoriano Sosa

If this list doesn't earn top 20 consideration then nothing would earn it.

 

Based on what?

Hes he making a comeback?

Will boxing fans become dumber?

I'll bet on the later.

 

DAMN THAT LIST LOOK NICE WITH SHANE, ANDRE, AND MANNY ON THEIR...HOW CAN SOMEONE HATE ON THIS? (LET ALONE THERE IS A LOT TO BE DONE WITH THOSE 3 FIGHTERS) STILL THOUGH..ALL THESE GUYS WERE TOPS IN THEIR DIVISION IF NOT TOP IN THE WORLD AT THE TIME...**** EVEN RICKY WAS RANKED 8 IN THE WORLD WHEN FLOYD KNOCKED HIM:hat

 

Low teens. Add Paul Williams and another belt at 154, low to mid teens.

 

Manny's rise in the ATG list had much to do with his move up in weight and beating some of the best dominantly. Floyd at the moment is no where near Manny on the ATG list. If he were to beat Shane and Manny and Berto he'd jump up a lot....but no one can do anything about Floyd's present resume. While very good it shy of greatness....beating Shane, Manny and Berto would bring his resume to an entirely new level. Besides PAC is not even breaking the top 10 atg at the moment.

 

And then 160, 175 and 200.

 

Top 40, maybe close to 30 if he looks amazing doing it.

 

thats like a Joe louis bum of the month club, and he wont fight Manny , even though I think he wins , the man just cannot accept that there are other fighters on his level.

 

Duran started at lightweight and he fought for the middleweight championship, not just any middleweight but hagler's linear championship.

PBF has to take more risks if he really wants to be compared to those guys.