Wins over Judah

Floyd's overall. Not only did he have problems in the early rounds just to only turn the tide, he kept himself cool even throughout the riot(could've been ruled a win for Judah by DQ since Roger stepped in) and started off where he left off to win. Cotto win was good too but I think Floyd takes the cake.

 

tszyu

 

I agree but he's not an option here. With those listed PBF.

 

Fmj

 

Notice how the cotto people aren't posting reasons why, I would love to hear this. How a man that Mayweather had previously beaten badly(it was going to be stopped if not for the riot) was a better win for Cotto than Mayweather?

On a side note, where is Carlos Baldomir's win over Judah?

 

floyd let zab have his moment in the fight, he said that he was waiting for zab to gas. against cotto judah had him hurt and he had to resort to cheating. against clottey judah lost by one round even if it only lasted 9 rounds.

 

Cotto won because of the 2 ridiculous low blows.

 

Cotto by far but floyd faced a more prime judah

 

care to explain

 

Tszyu :good

but for the poll, ill vote Money Mayweather!!

 

It's hard to say:

Cotto took the most damage, but his fight was the most entertaining and he actually had to fight through adversity

Floyd had some trouble early, but I thought was on his way to a stoppage if not for that low blow

Clottey is the only guy who I felt was never really having any trouble at all in the fight, seemed in complete control from opening Bell. I'd say, based on styles, Clottey did the best with him.

 

All the top fighters he faced beat his ass.

from that list i would pick Cotto.

 

cotto beat his ass. Judah didn't win a single round he didn't pull off a sharp counter shot that stunned Cotto. He did it a few times and won those exact rounds. But when it came down to boxing, Judah had no answers or game plan. Cotto had him from beginning to end outside of those stiff counter blows that Judah landed.

 

Clottey - Clottey dominated him start to finish.

Cotto - He took it to Cotto. Cotto cheated.

FMJ - FMJ had a rough time in the beginning, but pulled it out like a pro. Still, Judah went into the second half ahead on the cards.