Wins over Judah

Tie
Mayweather and Cotto
Judah was catching floyd with some sneaky punches Floyd over came
Judah was landing some ****ing Bombs on Cotto I thought he was gonna knock Cotto the **** Out eventually wtf happened lol cotto over came. I cant choose
If he had beat Cotto I would have been like Good Job Zab Knew you still had
If he beat Mayweather I wouldv been like WTF just Happened? Didnt Baldo just beat him?

i dont know lol

 

#1 :good

Then Cotto, Balthazar, and Blood Clottey.

 

I thought the Cotto fight was the most impressive.

Cotto didn't dominate him from start to finish, he had initial trouble where he was getting caught with flush counter uppercuts and up until the 5th round a Judah win seemed plausible. But Cotto slightly adjusted and exerted enormous pressure to subsequently break him down over the course of the fight not just beating him but beating him up in the process. Incidentally it was the most decisive win of the 3 listed.

The Mayweather fight comes a close second. Floyd after some initial trouble adjusted and followed his corner's instructions to take the fight to him. Floyd made a few subtle changes to overcome the speed deficit and successfully boxed his ears off. It slowly became a clinic. IMO Mayweather would have gotten a stoppage had it not been for that low blow which led to the riot.

The Clottey fight comes last because frankly Judah was still in the fight evidenced by the close scores. I had it even going into the 9th round and even if you don't agree with my score I'm certain that nobody who watched all three fights had the Cotto and Mayweather fights this close in terms scoring going into the 9th. By the time Zab was going into the 9th round with Floyd or Miguel he was already out of the fight in terms of scoring and momentum.

 

Balthazar :huh

 

bka Baldomir spell check is a mofo! :yep

 

Cotto is leading despite the crushing low blows? :blood

 

can't believe all these idiots said cotto! he was getting his ass whipped before he low blowed judah TWICE with very clan hard shots! i like cotto and think he's a good guy, but he's still a dirty fighter. and he slammed clottey in their fight. when cotto's in trouble, he usually gets a little dirty. pac and margarito were too fast and strong for cotto respectiviely. judah kicked cotto's ass up until the low blows.

 

That's because Cotto is loved here and PBF is hated. Anyone with a brain knows which win was better.:deal

 

Clottey.

 

Cotto fought with a cut in which he was bleeding profusely during the fight. He pulled through and won. I should add that the cut was more of a hindrance than the low blows.

Nobody who picked Cotto is an idiot. I'm certainly not.

The fact is the Cotto win was the most decisive in terms of scoring and in terms of the final result. Judah was finished after that fight.

If you picked Mayweather, and you think that it was the right choice then you must concede that Floyd was getting beat as was Cotto. Unlike Cotto however, the fight went to the cards with the closest score being a 4 point deficit.

If you picked Clottey, that was the closest fight of the 3 and going into the 9th round it was an even fight on 2 of the judges scorecard. This one really has no claim if you consider the circumstances.

And don't sit here make it look like everyone who is not picking Floyd Mayweather is attributed to hate, that **** doesn't apply to me.

 

I love Cotto & Floyd but thought Mayweather's win over Judah was better. Clottey isn't my #1 because the fight was closer than people think but a clear Clottey win.

 

finally saw judah-clottey. anybody else think judah won at least a couple of those rounds. i know clottey did a lot more damage with his shots, just though judah was in the fight though he woulda lost even without the cut stoppage

 

Mayweather. He was getting slapped like a *****. Repeatedly. And dug it out beautifully. Floyd did it clean. Showed the heart and determination of a champion. That was a wicked version of Judah.

Surprised to see Cotto winning this. Judah barely contested the fight.

 

cotto whooped that ass.

 

Tszyu's win over Zab should be on this list. I don't know why you'd leave it out to honest. I thought Cotto's win over Zab was a great fight.