Is Manny Pacquiao a top 12 all time great

hahaha that cracked me up....i know what ya mean tho

 

nothings really changed since last night, solid top 20

 

Robinson
Langford
Greb
Armstrong
Charles
Duran
Leonard
Leonard
Pep
Walker
Walcott
Burley
Ross
Gans
Fitzsimmons
Louis
Tunney
Whitaker
Arguello
Jones Jr
Monzon
Ali
Saddler
Moore
Canzoneri
McLarnin
Hagler

I can't see a good case at the moment for ranking him above these guys. Probably a few other's I've forgotten at first thought.

 

i can

 

very fair list...

 

u dont even know who most of those fighters are ON THAT LIST..LMFAO:rofl:rofl U KNOW 1 FIGHTER..MANNY PACQUIAO AND ANYTHING GOING ON AROUND HIM...THAT LIST IS VERY FAIR AND ALOT OF THOSE GUYS (MOST) ARE ON A LEVEL ABOVE MANNY ON MOST PEOPLES LISTS:deal

GO AHEAD AND START..TELL ME ABOUT CARLOS MONZON...LMFAO...CAN'T TALK BOXING WITH THESE GUYS..THEY ONLY KNOW MANNY PAC AND THEY PRETEND LIKE THEY BEEN WATCHING FOR YEARS..LMFAO:happy:happy

 

Still top 20 in my eyes. Floyd will put him in the top 15....beating Shane along with Floyd top 10.

 

around top 30-25

 

I think I'd have him ahead of McLarnin, Hagler, Saddler, RJJ, Arguello and Tunney.

It's all subjective though and, like I said, it doesn't really matter. Pacquiao is a great fighter who can be mentioned alongside anyone.

 

Far from it. Great fighter but there are more than twelve, more than twenty and arguable even more than 30 fighters who did better things than him.

 

:good

 

Since the 1970's, can anyone rank any boxer above Pac?

The only ones in contention are the top 25 ATG: Roberto Duran, Julio Cesar Chavez, George Foreman, and Muhammad Ali base on ESPN's 50 Greatest Boxers of All-Time.

I won't touch pre-1970's boxers.

 

I love how some people(must be *******s) say yes, and I bet that most of them don't know **** about the other ATGs.

 

Not saying this is my list, but arguments can be made for:

Oscar
Whitaker
Tyson
Leonard
Mayweather
Hagler
Roy Jones? (Maybe I'm reaching with this one)
Lennox Lewis
Holyfield
Hearns


I probably missed another 10 or 20

 

atsch