If Mayweather beats Mosley (clearly) who is P4P #1?

which ever way you wanna cut it mosleys number 3 4 or 5 on every respectable list

 

Your answer to the thread was?

So according to you, if Joshua Clottey had beaten Pacqiuao he would have become P4P #1

Actually according to you if Koki Komeda beats Pacqiuao, Koki Komeda becomes P4P #1.

P4P is based on a string of good wins not if you beat the current #1

 

Manny Pacquiao

The winner of Mayweather/Mosley vs Pac will decide if there's a new P4P king or if Pac stays atop the throne.

 

If koki komeda can come up to 147 and do it?
Abso****inglutely.

 

pac

 

forget who goes where

one question does the p4p number 1 have to loose or retire or become inactive to loose the spot like a linear title

 

loose?

twice??
Educate yourself on something.... spelling or boxing, take your pick.

 

What if Hopkins beats RJJ, Dawson and Haye

while Koki Komeda beats Pac

since you said

That means according to you, Koki Komeda ranks higher than Hopkins, if that given scenario occurs? Thus Koki Komeda remains Number 1 P4P. IF that scenario occurs

 

pac deservidly so p4p top by virtue of his post marquez perfomance starting with diaz,oscar ,hatton,cotto,an clottey an the relative ease he beat them all with frw lw to ww but ww king still belongs to shane no matter how you spin it

 

dont put yourself through this again , petty insults and childish behavoir

answer the question or stfu

 

If Mayweather dominates Mosley, (and Mosley doesn't look completely shot in the ring) there may be an argument for him being #1.

If the bout is even remotely close, then you have to stay with Pac by default until another big fight happens or Mayweather gets in the ring with Pac.

 

If you don't understand what I meant when I said "the guy who beats pac" then you're a ****ing moron.

Let me guess. Uneducated floyd fan trolling the board in hopes of finding more floyd supporters to sway the balance?

"hey guys, I know floyd won every round against marquez and couldn't be #1, but if he beats up old mosley, then can we convince people?"

The answer is no.
Move on.

 

I refuse to debate people who can't spell simple words.
Did you drop out, or did you seriously live the past 21 years of your life thinking there were 2 o's in lose?

 

pac has been miles ahead of floyd or any other in the p4p list by now. not even floyd beating mosley would change this.

 

Manny would still be the man officially, but Mayweather would be the man unofficially. Both camps would have an argument.