I'm sure theres some who might pick Paul, but I'm going with Nando. I really cant see Tall Paul handling the 99-00 Vargas. Vargas was too strong, and had the skills and accuracy to expose Paul's leaky defense. Plus Vargas was heavy handed enough to wear Williams down. It took a prime Tito, and a close to prime DLH to beat Vargas, and I dont see overrated Paul being on that level. Vargas by either UD, or maybe a late TKO.
Yeah right, I wouldnt go that far. Vargas was COMPLETELY shot in the Mayorga fight. Paul gives that Vargas a beating. I'm talking about the Vargas that beat Campas, Marquez,, Wright and Quartey. THAT Vargas beats Williams. And also, that Vargas woulda beaten the **** outta Mayorga.
that vargas got a gift against winky. paul would decision him by just out working him no straight ahead fighter has ever given P-Dub any real :heyproblems.
vargas is pretty overrated...a guy who mustered only 26 wins and lost in the all the biggest fights...he was good yes....did well in his losses, but lost...
well look at the guys he lost too, would you think Williams would perform better than Vargas did? I think not.
Yeah but he only lost to GREAT fighters.... not 2nd raters like Carlos Quintana. I guarantee you that Vargas wouldnt have needed a 2nd try to destroy a Carlos Quintana.
A prime Tito woulda sent Paul to the ER within 6-7 rounds. Its unbeliavable how overrated Paul Williams is.
It wasnt a gift but it was very close, i actually scored it a draw. Vargas came on late and Winky didnt do much in the last couple rounds. Im going with Vargas by razor close decison. Or i can see him stopping Williams late. Actually this is a pretty good matchup im 60/40 on Vargas.
Very True:yep:good No way Would a prime Vargas ever have lost to Quintana, he would have knocked him out the first time around.
i love thi threa im a fan of both if not for mis management and a severe back einjury vargas is a sure fire hof won his 1st title 12 fights n and was 21 when he fought a prime tito whoe he had ko if not for a dead shot n the cods he wasnt ready for that fight and never was the same he was on his way to b the next hagler just wasnt meant to b he was beating moseley n the 1st fight till it got stopped on a 2nd head cming up that being said pw is no cake walk for anybody wouldve been a great fight but kinda trick question dont think we ever seen vargas reach his prime