Who Would Dare To Claim Hopkins Is Ahead Of Calzaghe On The ATG List

please dont start this again, im sick to death of Calzaghe threads and i loved the guy as a fighter.

 

u dumb *******
its unblemished because 95% of his career he fought garbage

 

Oh, brother...20 pages of bull**** to ensue from a bull**** thread. Yayyyy.

 

I claim that Hopkins is ahead of Calzaghe on the ATG list.

There you go.

 

Hopkins fought
G. Johnson (undefeated)
Trinidad (undefeated)
De La Hoya (first man to K.O him)
Pavlik (undefeated)
Tarver (jumped 2 divisions to face him for the lineal title)
RJJ (undefeated + last night)
Winky (tough fight for anyone)
Calzaghe (undefeated)

The only man he didnt defeat on that list is Calzaghe

He fought some lesser names like

Taylor
Echols
Joppy

Calzaghe fought
Lacy (undefeated)
Bika
Kessler (undefeated)
Hopkins
RJJ

I think its clear that Hopkins fought and defeated better fighters overall and by that logic he is greater

 

NOOOOOO!!!! don't keep this thread going...****, I'M keeping this thread going

 

this
calzhage isnt even in the same ballpark as far as legacy with hopkins

 

Ffs i used to love calzaghe. but his post retirement attitude and that of fans like you have put me right off him! veit is so wank i aint even gonna justify it...i want joe to come back an fight froch an get kayod!

 

Wined-up Threadatsch

 

Wait, so Calzaghe never carefully picked opponents?

 

Calzaghe did not go near America when everyone over there was in their prime. He ducked Froch and at lightheavy ignored Clinton Woods. He was very good...a legend... but unbeaten does not make you a great..he was a 'fed homeboy' who never travelled other than to fight 'oldmen' in money making nonsense fights...sorry Bernard Hopkins is above Joe Calzaghe


Errol Chin

 

this thread is thanks to me.....


I can't say who should rank higher if calzaghe had hopkins record I'm pretty sure he would still be undefeated...

maybe would have a loss against glen johnson ... i'm not sure

 

[YT]wrauy1uQYQY&[/YT]