Comparing Vitali, Wlad and Haye

Power -
(1st) Wlad gets the edge here, may not be as explosive as Haye but i think he does hit harder.
(2nd) Haye, people may disagree with me here but i think Haye may hit a little than Vitali now, prime for prime the edge would go towards Vitali.
(3rd) Vitali, clearly out of his prime and only threw arm punches in his last bout.

General Speed -
Haye probably has a clear edge here being the smaller man coming up to heavyweight.
Wlad has a fast one two.
Vitali has clearly slowed down over the years.

Chin -
Vitali has a very clear edge here over the other two.
Wlad has been stopped a number of times although he has not been Knocked out cold.
Haye has been down a number of times and was stopped earlier in his career although he was still on his feet. His punch resistance will be a huge deciding factor in a fight with either Klit

Offensive Skill -
Haye takes this for me due to his variety and his aggressive style whilst on the attack.
Vitali takes this over his brother due to his willingness to attack and put unbearable pressure on his opponent, on a side note he would still be nightmare for any heavy in history with his impressive workrate.
Wlad seems unwilling to finish opponents when he has a clear opportunity but has proved that he has one punch power in either hand, his lack of willingness to finist an opponent off could be fatal in a fight with Haye.

Defensive Skills -
Wlad has a style which has proved very difficult to break down, much of his defence lies with battering ram jab and his fast footwork.
Haye proved against Ruiz that he was very good at avoiding punches on the defensive with slick headmovement and clever footwork, still room for improvement.
Vitali does'nt really have to rely on his defence due to his chin and his ability to put his opponent on the backfoot.

Mental toughness -
I feel Haye has proved himself in this department time and time again, took on Enzo Macc in what many saw as a 50/50 fight and snatched a belt from Mormeck in a foriegn country after a KD.
Vitali showed incredible heart against Lewis proving he could take a punch as well as give one, should not have quit against Byrd.
Wlad has been proven to press the panick button when in trouble.

Stamina
Vitali has proven stamina and threw over 800 punches against Arreola.
Haye gassed against Thompson which led to his one and only defeat.
Wlads style has largely stopped the occurance of Wlad gassing although it is still a question mark in the back of his mind, might explain his reluctance to finish an opponent off. Interchangeable with Haye in this case

Experience
Wlad has over 50 fights and has a slight edge over his big bro
Vitali has a wealth of experience and has shared a ring with ATG Lewis
Haye's experience is not to be sneered at despite only having 24 bouts, hes held 3 belts at cruiserweight and now holds the WBA belt up at heavy.

Ive tried to be unbiased, please give feedback or complete your own list

or add to the list if i agree with something then i will copy and paste

 

thanks man, i was not quite sure how to compare ther chins, its very debatable:good

 

This has been going around in my head for weeks, Vitali has an ATG chin but little head movement, Haye has the capacity to explode very fast hooks from odd angles, if Vitali sees them then he will most likely take them, if he doesnt see them then it anyones guess to what happens.

Cant remember who said this but they said "Power thrills, Speed kills" that could very well apply to a future fight between these two.:good

 

im probably not the best person to rate the three but i felt haye proved a lot about how good his defence can become bearing in mind he didnt get much sparring in for this bout.

 

you come across as desperate to prove a point, yet ive already stated how i was trying to be unbiased.

you mention that Haye has a crap defence yet you fail to notice that Haye had little sparring for the fight, he also didnt get hit anywhere near the amount your stating, what you fail to realise is that Haye was very good at setting traps for Ruiz, letting Ruiz come forward and throw punches is part of the plan to walk the guy onto puches. Haye done this all night.

secondly Wlad panics when put under pressure, its not all that hard to see.

As for your last comparisons as much as your trying to prove a point and belittle the list ive made, i actually agree with it although stamina is a toss up between Haye and Wlad:tong

 

sorry my bad

 

this is true, Haye doesnt do road work:good