1. manny pac 2. floyd may 3. shane mos 4. paul wil 5. chad dawson 6. jmm 7. hozumi hasegawa 8. tim bradley 9. pongsaklek wonjakam 10. ivan caulderon bscene top 10 p4p dirrell last 2 wins better than ivan caulderon & ponsaklek wonjakam
dirrell is good. he lost to froch as you just can't come to someones hometown and expect to steal rounds, it just doesn't work out like that. a rematch between dirrell and froch i would expect dirrell to win by a few rounds. he's good, but he needs to step it up when he fights out of america.
who ivan caulderon or pongsaklek wonjakam faught thats worth a damn? dirrell got robbed against the 1# guy @ 168 then stepped up and beat the new #1 guy @168 these past 2 wins are better than anyone elses past 2 wins in boxing... outside of pacquiao maybe
:huh You dont judge the fights mate. Ergo, he lost. He didnt "shut-out" Abraham either. And even if he did, it wouldnt put him near P4P top 10. Now, I had the Froch fight close but I dont rate Froch all that highly. As such, for Dirrell to struggle so much against him puts a negative against Dirrell. It was also easy to see, before the fight, that Dirrell could outbox AA. Dirrell's style lent itself to a UD over AA. Obviously it never quite got that far, but that's where it was heading. Ward beating Kessler is actually the bigger accomplishment for me, putting Ward higher in the P4P lists than Dirrell (but still not top 10). All in all, I suppose what I'm trying to say is that you are way, way off the mark.
I would think this was just another Danny Rand/Michegan Warrior alias, but this one seems somehow shriller and more stupid, impossible though it sounds...
I really don't like agreeing with that guy, since he is a total tool, but i have to say he is getting close. The reason being: AA was possibly top 10 p4p before the fight, and while the win doesn't do much more than #4 or #5 at 168, it does something p4p. I don't have him top 10 yet, but he is top 20 for me.