Very few legitimate ways to discredit either Ward or Dirrell here. Dirrell "made it close" against seasoned champion, Froch, in his 18th pro fight, and outboxed Abraham in his 19th. Ward dominated veteran de facto king of the division in his 20th. These are kids who were prospects fighting journeymen 1 fight prior. Its pretty clear to the unbiased eye they are the "creme of the crop" as you put it.
Ward is #1 for me, Dirrell still has a lot to prove to be at #2. I wouldve guessed WMM could put forth a better list, without totally discrediting the other fighters.
What the ****!? :silly Green hasn't beaten anyone at SMW Abraham was just hammered by Dirrel and he's above Kessler who beat Froch? And Bute at #7?! The general forum is starting to look and feel like something from the Twilight Zone. :nut Edit: Ah only four posts. Another alternate account made for trolling....
1-Ward: Comprehensively beat the man at the time. 2-Bute: Made short work of Andrade and Miranda, both dangerous opponents. 3-Kessler: Like it or not, he beat Froch who was arguably the most accomplished fighter at the weight. 4-Froch: Close defeat to Kessler the only blemish after beating Pascal, Taylor and Dirrel 5-Dirrel: Would be above Froch had their fight been held in the USA. Was outboxing Abraham.
@OP Asinine is a good word to describe your recent posts. Biggest ****ing crybaby I've seen in a while, over a close fight, too. In defense of Carl ****ing Froch as well. That beak bearing ***** doesn't deserve any sympathy for losing a close fight. 1. Ward 2. Bute 3. Kessler 4. Dirrell 5. Abraham 6. Froch Green doesn't really belong in any top lists at this point imo.
How in hell can Ward be #1 - his best two wins are vs. an over hyped and old #7 Kessler and a not even ranked Miranda..................:think..................and why are Bute #2 - he is 1-1 vs. Andrade, who was scholed by this over hyped old stif Kessler - and then a win vs. this Miranda guy again.........its very strange...............:huh
the american guy the other american guy the north american guy the eurobums allan green. something like that - seriously how anyone can rank Dirrel in the top 3 is beyond me, he must be below Froch, Kessler & Ward in the Super 6 and I am sure below Bute too. All the kid has done is beat MW.
Bute is 2-0 against Andrade but you have to know to count up to 8 to know it. Kessler was not shot when he beat Andrade. He is now. Andrade is better now than he was against Kessler. He can win on points against guys like Stieglitz and Tsypko, a thing he could not do before. We can go like this for a long time. The truth is no one is right. All this are opinions. When Bute will fight the super 6 fighters, we'll know.
lmfao...gift to froch..wow...even if it was a "gift u should still rank him higher than that... its like this...if the ref rules it a knockdown but as a judge i clearly saw it was a slip..i cant start makin my own **** up..i gotta rule it a knockdown... :deal horrible list really 1 Ward 2 Bute 3 Kessler 4 Froch 5 Dirrell 6 AA 7 Green 8 Bika 9 Andrade 10 Steiglitz