Who does better against pacquiao shane or floyd????

PBF would box circles around Pac and not get busted up. Shane might win but he would take a lot of punishment in the process.

 

Mayweather only because he is more defensive minded and arguably a better technician than Shane. Mayweather would outbox Pac as JMM outboxed Pac.

Shane would brawl with Pac, which Pac would draw him into. That might be his undoing. Still, this fight would almost be even and certainly more exciting than Pac v Maweather.

 

Honestly I think both of them would beat Pacquio. Floyd in a one sided match making Pacquiao look stupid. And Shane in a more brawling type of fight trading type of fight. That opinion may change in a few days, but as of now, I see Mayweather beating them both, but I can't say Pacquiao is better than Shane. At least not till May 2nd depending on how he fights.

 

Floyd's style allows him to compete with Pac at equal level, where its really hard to pick the underdog

 

:good

 

If that was the case he would have fought Shane instead of Cotto.:deal

 

They both beat him. Shane by KO. Mayweather by wide UD.

 

Mayweather

 

floyd has more speed so I pick Floyd. He could counter everything Pacman has, but Shane fought evenly with Cotto who was beaten up by Pacman.

 

shane stops him
floyd wins a desion

 

Hmm I picked floyd initially, however I think Shane may pull off a more convincing win if he pulls off combination counters a la marquez that look crisp and flush, with the power making Pac respect him. It would be more risky for shane since he may get tagged more, so he would have to show enormous heart for his age, many fold more than when he fought cotto.

Floyd on the other hand may pull a close UD or SD due to the sheer difference in work rate clouding the number of clean punches landed by floyd.

 

I voted floyd but its pretty even..

 

Probably Mayweather...stylistically, I see him giving Pacquiao the most trouble.
Pacquiao would use his foot speed to get at Mosley, although it would be a war. If the bout turned into a scrap between Mosley and Pacquiao, Mosley would have a very good chance.

 

Both guys outclass Pac and probably knock him out.