frankenspank you are ****ing bat**** mate. Just for fun lets try this though.. 10) Rocky Marciano vs 1) Sam Langford 9) Salvador Sanchez vs 2) Henry Armstrong Manny Pacquiao vs 6) Julio Cesar Chavez 7) Thomas Hearns vs 7) Hector Camacho 6) Joe Louis vs 3) Mike Tyson 5) Marvin Hagler vs 8) Mike Mcallum 4) Sugar Ray Leonard vs 9) Marlon Starling 3) Pernell Whitaker vs 5) Roberto Duran 2) Mohammed Ali vs 10) David Tua 1) Sugar Ray Robinson vs 4) James Toney
Ah, missed it. Well under your criteria, I disagree with Hearns, Pacquiao and, though I hate to say it, Hagler. If I was you I would consider: Charley Burley Kid Gavilan (ww is so stacked) Ezzard Charles Carlos Monzon
For starters, I'd favor the guys who actually beat Foreman and Hearns H2H in their best weight classes.
(1) This is a P4P list you idiot , not a H2H. (2.1) many posters here , but not me , are pretty much sure JCC would have killed Pac. (2.2) Tyson would have put Joe Louis in E.R. at every point of Louis' prime. (2.3) Whitaker vs. Duran is a very controversial one , don't use it as an argument. (2.4) Frazier and Shavers put Ali down. I think some much worse fighters did it long before them when Ali was prime and fresh. Where is TGA to post them cases now ? (2.5) And despite Toney had some poor performances at 160 , when he was drained , SRR also had his struggles with smaller men , without the drained excuse even. Toney at 160 , could be out of top10 all time , but he sure was something at higher weights mostly , and that was being chronically the smaller man (except Griffin). But then again (#1) you don't know what P4P is.
You've just quit on your stool, and you have the nerve to call Roberto Duran! Anyway, thanks for letting me know what is and what isn't cool. keyboard warrior. I appreciate that.
No Barney Ross? Or Walker, 2 guys that made the name pound for pound, mean pound for pound lol. Ok Fitz did that, (And he should be there also.)