atschatschTerrible list...........3 of those guys got THRASHED in their last fight and David Haye is SOOOOOOOOOOOOO untested........... Chad Dawson #4....WOW........worst group of Elite fighters I've seen in a while..
Manny is still number 1. He still has the better resume, and his current form is better because Mayweather-Marquez was a mismatch, and Pac's defeat of Cotto was better than Floyd's win over Mosley IMO.
I'd probably have manny number 1 but its tight, i think floyd the better fighter but manny record is better than mayweather. Hopefully they get it on and we can decide
mosley is a better opponent then clottey but, hatton,cotto,clottey> marquez,mosley so pac is still number 1, but mayweather can easily take that recognition by beating pac.
I know you don't rate Clottey all that highly, so I'm guessing you would agree that FMJ's win over Mosley was better than Pac's over Clottey. But Pac's win over Cotto was better than JMM.
It would have taken a KO of Mosley to put Mayweather above Pac on the P4P list... Though I think Mayweather is clearly the man at WW.
Marquez and Mosley were #2 and #3 P4P when Mayweather fought them and Cotto was #5 when Manny fought him. Plus, Mayweather beat the crap out of Hatton before Manny did so you can't use that as an argument for Manny. :hi: