A depressingly **** P4P top ten. Donaire at 4, Mosley STILL above Dawson. Caballero!, no Klitschko's and Koki Kameda's conquerer. What a motley bunch!
I would have Ward top 15. Bute not even 25. you can vote on the Official ESB forum ratings here. This content is protected
Montiel is more accomplished than Caballero and also the better fighter, Nonito has to go i had him at the bottom last week but after Montiels impressive win Nonitos out.
Caballero doesn't deserve to be on there. Haven't seen Donaire fight but 23-1 isn't exactly a good record... might as well put Khan at number 3 with that type of **** going on. Martinez beat Williams so he should be ahead of him. Mayweather 1, Pacquiao 2 would be more appropriate. Add in Pongsaklek Wongjongkam to round out the list and you have one of the shittiest lists ever.
Wonjongkam in there is a joke, Donaire at 4 is a travesty, there records contain one win of note each, and a list of total unknowns. Dawson and Williams should be higher. Wlad Klitchsko should have made an appearance after owning another good contender in Eddie Chambers. Im also very surprised that Mosley is still there, if he is there then why is Cotto not also there? They are in the same position, looking awful against the 2 best P4P'ers. I usually respect the Ring's ratings, but this one is awful.
I agree with your opinions on these guys. I see they kicked the bosses out of the PFP ranking Actually i still have him hanging on but only by default soon he will be pushed out. My top 10. 1 FLoyd 2.Manny 3.Marquez 4.Martinez i also thought he beat Williams 5.Williams 6.Dawson 7.Montiel 8.Bradley 9.Mosley 10.Holpkins Ward about to kick out Hopkins if he wins impressively next time. Hell if he wins the Super 6(looking good) he might take Marquezs spot.
One thing the ring got right that many on ESB havent, is that the Klits arent top 10 PFP more like top 12 to 15.
Detiriated but not shot he is a great fighter and the toughest WW has to offer. If Pac wants to keep his spot he knows what he has to do ...:deal