Why wasnt there a Investigation into the 119-110 card in the Williams-Martinez Fight?

The judge in Dimitrenko-Chambers who gave it a draw was the biggest disgrace ever.

 

boogles and bin are the best words in this thread so far.

 

It's what they call a German Draw. It's what happens in Germany when their hometown favorite gets schooled but not knocked out. It's like a Texas draw, only more European.

 

He got schooled and knocked down twice if I remember.. was a farce when they said MD.

 

worse than the judge that scored 118-110 for Sugar Ray against Hagler?

 

Because Williams was the hometown fighter?

 

Judges who sabotage scorecards should be beaten to death! Thats how sick of it i am.

Its about time we made these inept judges accountable. They should have to explain in a press conference after the fight exactly how and why they scored each round.

Or even better...stop these old farts judging fights altogether bring new rules in, such as only an ex fighter is qualified to judge

 

because almost all of those rounds were close rounds to score, depending on what you were looking for.


How is that scoredcard worse than any of the ones from Cintron-Martinez????

 

now that is a true disgrace. that is an actual "robbery." word gets used to much on here but that's a fight where its applicable.

 

Iv sat and watched numerous fights where iv almost trashed my living room in anger when i heard some of these outrageous scorecards.

Cotto Vs Clottey- an absolute robbery. one judge scored i think 116-111 to cotto which was unnacceptable.

Lewis vs holyfield- an outrage

Diaz vs Malignaggi- unbelievable.

Some judges clearly sabotage scorecards....those judges should be kicked in the head then arrested to face criminal charges

 

There is a lot of that type of stuff going on in the states, if your going there you need to win big or face the consequences, hometown fighers are heavily backed by officials

 

I scored it 116-115 Martinez, 5 rounds to 4 for Maravila with 3 even. The fact that I had 3 even rounds underline how difficult it was to score, it's one of the trickiest fights to score I've ever watched.

I would not argue at all with anyone who scored it for Williams by a similarly slim margin, but I think there definitely should be an investigation or something into a 119-110 scorecard in that fight because that is completely unjustifiable and basically just ****ing ludicrous.

 

Just as bad I'd say. Both of those cards are ****ing horrendous.

 

williams is a mob fighter, thats why he's avoided