ESB P4P Top Ten List

That list is nothing short of disguisting !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :twisted::firehi::|

 

Lists not bad but you need to get Benson out of there like two posts ago.

 

Fedor
GSP
Anderson Silva
Shogun Rua
Jose Aldo
Frank Edgar
BJ Penn
Lyoto Machida
Dominick Cruz
Joseph Benavidez

 

#1- Fedor- What can you say? The guy has heavy hands, great submissions, the ability to adapt, and a stone cold mindset. And he always closes the show. Easily #1


#2- GSP- The mans athletic ability and Silva's lack of performance puts GSP in the #2 spot, but just barely.

#3- Anderson Silva- I bumped Silva to the #3 spot because of his hit and miss performances. Sometimes he does great and shows his skill, other times he just hot dogs and shows off for the crowd, even though they are not impressed. Anderson just isn't worth the risk of dropping $60 on PPV. You don't know what you will get


That is as far as I go. 1,2,3. Nothing else really matters beyond that.

 

1. Fedor

2. Anderson/GSP
4. Penn/Shogun


the rest is not important

 

Actually yes it is when you rank Penn so highly but ignore Frankie Edgar.

 

Good post, I agree.

 

the obivous top 3 are Fedor, GSP and Silvia. The rest of the ten can go to many fighters. Shogun, penn, hendo, Machida etc

 

he has to prove himself a longer time. penn is a top 5 p4p for at least 5 years

 

Frank Edgar beat BJ Penn thats enough said.

 

+1 Why even fight if you don't end up higher ranked than the guys you beat? I guess Penn should be able to keep his lightweight belt too?

Should Chuck Lidell be in the top 10 p4p? He was a p4p fighter for many many years as well. Penn deserves to be in the top 10, no doubt, but he doesn't deserve a spot in front of Edgar, the guy who JUST beat him.

 

1) Fedor
2) GSP
3) Silva
4) Shogun
5) Aldo
6) Shields
7) Edgar
8) Penn
9) Fitch
10) Machida

I did that in about 30 seconds so maybe it needs some adjusti ng, but I like it like that for right now.

Also, it's weird that it stars out "J U S T I N" in any order. ******.

 

obviously u missed the thread about evans being better than fedor