Where do you currently rank Mayweather on the P4P ATG list?

Bladegunner. Lol.

 

I dunno, somewhere in the top 40 maybe? Yep, somewhere in the 40's.

 

My list:

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Mike Tyson
3. Chuck Liddell
4. LL Cool J
5. Floyd Mayweather, Jr.



I know some people will flame me for having Liddell over Cool J but that's just the way I see it.

 

Kinda depends. I rate him above mayweather as of right now because I think his weight class domination is more impressive in the P4P sense. 7 weight classes? Can't **** with that. I rank him similarly to RJJ, somewhere in the 30's. If May-Pac happens then the rankings may change, but even then i might still have Pac over him. If Pac wins then I would rank him higher than RJJ. If Mayweather wins he would move into the 30's for me. Haven't quite decided.

Both fighters are hard to call, because their toughest tests are yet to come and I'm not sure how long their careers will continue.

 

Mayweather Top 35-40
Pac-Top 25-30

 

PBF top 30-35. Pac top 15-20.

 

You dont have legendary champ Nallege in your top five,thats blasphemy.

 

:rofl

 

NALLEGE is #8, behind Rey Mysterio and Kristi Yamaguchi.

 

if you think pac is actualy greater then mayweather in an ATG list then please switch to another forum, actualy scrap that, start watching a different sport LOL wow the amount of assholes that jump on the hype machine/bandwagon its unbeleivable, and you guys actualy call your self enthusiasts/purists of the sport? LMAO ....

 

Excellent 1st post. Welcome to ESB. :-(




Just FYI, Pacquiao is almost universally considered higher on that list according to pretty much every boxing analyst in the world. I guess nobody knows anything about boxing, right?

 

60-70

Somewhere behind pryor and tyson.