Hypothetical Match Up Game

Hmm...This is a tough one. I go for Fitzimmons if it's by his era's rules. Otherwise I select Foster. Jose Torres v Matthew Saad Muhammad

 

Saad Muhammad UD
Gerry Cooney vs Ingemar Johanson

 

Ingo has trouble getting in on the llong reach of Cooney. Until the left hook lands & both of Johanssens legs are twitching!

Miguel Cotto .Vs. Carlos Ortiz @ 140.

 

Ortiz has too much experience for Cotto at that weight, and might be able to hurt him purely because of that i reckon, Ortiz can fight at any range, he'd be better at any range too i think. Ortiz for me.

Cory Spinks vs Carlos Palomino

 

Nelson via late rounds tko. Good fight. Jimmy Young v Young Stribling ?

 

Stribling on points,busier man. Jimmy good on defense,but doesn't want to open up.

Buddy McGirt.Vs. Sauol Mamby. 12 rounds.

 

Saoul Mamby is competetive at times but for the most part to laid back Mcgirt outhustles him and even outboxes him. Mcgirt 116-112.


Oba Carr-Hedgemon Lewis?

 

Same could be said about Carr. talented fighter, but didn't show full potential. Lewis too much in any regard. Lewis UD.

Jose Luis Castillo .Vs. John Montes Jr.

 

Castillo by merciless execution.

Hector Camacho Sr. v Floyd Mayweather Jr. at 130

 

Before i answer the last post id have to say i disagree with you about Carr not fulfilling his talent. He showed he was a very good fighter but all his shots were against great fighters ODLH,TIto and near great Quartey. Carr was very competetive with all of them, in alot of other eras he would have won a title and make a few defenses. That being said Carr and Lewis are a pretty even matchup. Montes was good but not in Castillos league.


Camacho was in his prime at JL and one of the best PFP guys at one time. Although Camacho has the edge here in speed,Mayweather would still be right there and Countering Camacho and discouraging, bottom line when you throw speed out the department Mayweather is a much better fighter than Macho. Mayweather also hit pretty hard at JL but no way would he stop Camacho. Camacho would take an early lead but by the middle rounds Mayweather will have already taken over and puts a whupping on in the late rounds. Mayweather 10-5


David Reid vs Davey Moore

 

Salvidar by late tko. Rocky Graziano v Nigel Benn.

 

Probably Benn, either man could win by stoppage, but maybe trying to slam home rights won't get it done. Graziano could defo do a Zale 2 job on him but i'll take Benn to stop his man with some ferocity.

Schmeling-Bruno