You make think its a bad thread but 14% of this Forum still believes Peter would win. And it is a legitimate arguement the two fighters had similar careers. Both are huge punchers, Peter is physically bigger and was able to outbox james Toney. And anything beats arguing the Mayweather vs Pacquiao soap opera. But your entitled to your opinion.
Dude Peter had a ruptrued ear drum in the fight with McCline for christsakes!!! Vitali is not a one punch ko artis right??? Vitali hit Peter with about 400 punches and could not knock in out or wobble him:hi:
Prime Tua would knock out Peter. I don't feel as though Peter is any better then Ike or Izon or Rahman. So I see his fate being simalar to Izon's but earlier. Peter likes to bang and Tua would be more then willing to do so as well. I will take Tua tko8!!
I think Peter's chin is better than that. He went 12 rounds taking bombs off of Wlad without being dropped and took a lot of punishment from Vitali without going down either. His chin seems pretty solid. Tua at his best would beat him though, zero doubt about it...by stoppage.
Tua is so everhyped its sad really... especially when his best wins were agains Ruiz... and a rahmen fight that should of been a no contest.
Tua has fought and tko/ko fighters in Ruiz, Rahman, Maskaev (who ko Rahman 2 times), Moorer, Oquendo.
Washed up moorer, Oquendo seriously Didnt Ruiz even ko him and like the only semi decent person ruiz has ever Ko'd? Maskaev the guy who was Ko'd by trex sanders yes the bad sanders not the good one., Rahmen i dont know what you are trying to prove he should have the Rahman ko removed because of the punch after the bell in a fight he was losing. also in the rematch isnt Tua the one who went down :huh Rahman who was ko'd twice by Maskaev and was the only decent heavy maskaev has ko'd .. If that wasnt about an average slightly chinny group of heavyweights... then what is. Rachman's only real claim to fame is he scored a lucky punch on a lewis who was toying with him then destroyed in the rematch...
So you call that a legit knockdown? Cause that was after the bell as well. But if you want to call it a legit knockdown then Tua tko Rahman was a legit one as well correct?
Oquendo, Rahman were both undefeated until Tua tko them. Tua is the first fighter to ko Ruiz in that was way way way way way way way before David did. Tua became the second fighter to ko Maskaev. Tua ko Moorer with a minute in the 1st round.