Are rematches always a good idea?

He would punch Donaire, Montiel, Darchinyan and Hasegawas faces in :deal

 

And Rob, a few things to your opening post. Haglers retirement negated a rematch with Leonard, not Hearns, who Couldve done nothing to neat Marv, bad matchup for Tommy IMO. I also find that fight overrated.

Greg, what of Hagler Vs Giardello?

 

Yep, and do it in an elegant way.

Speaking of rematches Moon vs Konadu II is a werid ass fight.

 

Rematches are responsible for a large part of the great history this sport has. Louis v Schmelling, Ali v Frasier right on to Morales v Barrera etc etc.

They are a must for the sport but only for the right reasons. An unfair result last time out, closely matched competitors, bad blood or just genuine rivalry they must exist.

If DeGale beats Groves on a split decision who wouldn't want a rematch for a few million more?

Diaz gave his all in the first fight and there was an argument for a rematch and for no rematch. Last night JMM proved once again he belongs on the very highest platform of the sport. And I hope they pay him a truckload and stick him in there with Khan coz he'll spank him and say "who's your Daddy."

 

Giardello is ****ing awesome at negating pressure but he relies on his jab alot. Hagler had a real good way of negating a jab and establishing his own. Its close as hell though. I could just imagine some of the counters being thrown by eahc man.

 

Elegant??? I'd be more inclined to say barbarically.

The 2nd fight is weird. Konadu just seems to realise early that he'll get hit even harder if he throws back so opts out until he gets pulled out, which shouldve happened MUCH sooner IMO.

Similar to Zapata-Chang II, I think they both said 'not this guy again, **** going through this again'

 

Moon epitome of elegence, in a crude sorta way.

Its not as blatant as Chang-Zapata II though, its mad stuff, the last thing Id want to do is be in a corner with Moon.

 

Did Ali fight Kelsey Grammar? Mismatch.

 

I just tutted, sighed and shook my head all at once. I aint done that in years.

 

Chavez wasnt at his unbeatable best either Rob

 

No, aslong as its evenly matched IMO.

Think Lupe Madera vs Katso Tokashiki, there first fight was near the ends of their primes and their 4th fight was at the ends of their career and was as good as the first.

 

Steady on.:nono