When thinking about an all-time ranking for Oscar De La Hoya...

touché, buddy!:good

 

I'd go with the latter, personally. Excellent fighter at his best, but he far from stacks up to the best I've ever seen.

 

I'd favor both Chavez and Nelson at 130-135, and likely by KO. I'd probably favor Oscar over Tszyu at 140, though. Bigger fighter, better footwork, more varied offensive arsenal. Perhaps his left hook would play the counter to Tszyu's right hand. Then again, Oscar's squared up stance could lead him to eat a few more of them than he needs to. All things considered I'd favor the Golden Boy.

 

So you will change your ranking of Barrera and Morales every time you rewatch their second fight then. By your own admission, you've scored it differently multiple times. Sometimes decisions are measured by the inch.

 

Well some fights I have a different scorecard every time I score it, I don't see the use in changing my rankings accordingly every time. If a fight is that debatable that even I can't settle a winner definitively either way, then I'd much rather go with the judges on the night.

 

What was your scorecard for Roberto Duran vs. Sugar Ray Leonard I?

 

I had it by 2. If I scored one round differently...I'd have had a draw.

 

If you score fights one way or the other whenever you watch them wouldn't it be logical to just call them even? It's not like your opinion of either fighter would change drastically regardless of how you scored it.