EAST SIDE BOXING P4P Rankings: VOTEING CLOSED RESULTS TODAY AT 12pm

Yes so Donaire really has one quality win on his resume. Meanwhile Montiel has fought basically all the top guys in his division and rarely cracks anyones top 10 list while Donaire is in almost everyones with just 1 major win.

 

1.Pacquiao
2.S Martinez
3.JMM
4.F Montiel
5.JM Lopez
6.T Bradley
7.Adamek
8.S Cunningham
9.R Marquez
10.Maidana

 

Objective is to list your P4P list, not your favorite fighters

 

Just because you dont go along dosent mean your wrong, all the fighters on the list are p4p quality.

 

Not even close.

Your list won't even be counted.

 

I think any list without Mayweather and Pacquiao at least in the top four should not be included.

The rest are negotiable but those two, IMO, are not.

 

They are the top two by a wide margin. There is nobody in boxing even close right now. Mayweather beat the previous #3 P4P 11-1 (10-2 for some).

He's just trolling but is a douche nonetheless.

 

Who has FM beat besides Mosley since 08? Why does almost every list include Dawson but not Montiel or JM Lopez? Why is Williams on it whos big fights are heavily disputed on it but no Cunningham? Why isnt Maidana on the lists when the only fight he lost is highly disputed? The problem in boxing is people that dont know and just go by the names they hear thrown around on sites like this one and in the media.

 

You can raise these arguments in another thread. You lose credibility here as this thread is a legitmate attempt to make an ESB P4P list and you submit a protest list.

For the record, FM also beat the #3 guy on your list since 08.

When has Cunningham, Maidana, etc got in the ring with anyone near JMM or Mosley's level?

 

Yea the #3 guy who is a lightweight Cunnuunigham and Maidana have been beating fighters in their weight classes alot of them by ko.Just because you dont hear about them in the media dosent mean their not there or their no good. And like I said already I dont understand why Montiel and Lopez are missing from these lists, when guys like Dawson who just got beat, Khan, or Donnaire are on them.

 

The East Side Boxing p4p Rankings are a piece of utter shite.

 

why?

in no way shape or form are they as bad as boxrec's.