pick 'n impartial poster 2 decide mythical matchup winners

Would you be willing to be the judge, M?

 

How 'bout you, CP, willing to tackle it?

 

Any recommendations or others willing to step-up as a judge?

 

Did you guys miss the debate thread?

 

Did someone on there propose this, i?

 

Sure, I'd like to step up as a judge.

 

You've certainly established your creds, S. Let's see how many others step-up, 'n who posters ratify.

 

Why not you JG?

You stay out of H2H match ups but have a superb knowledge on most boxers as well as superb technical analytical skills through a life time of the fight game.

 

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=246423

 

Is that a nice way of sayin' I'm very old, GP? Thanks for the props, but not interested, just tired of seein' guys go round 'n round without resolution.

How 'bout you? You're certainly a student of the game.

 

Theres better guys for the job than me. I dont really have the time these days anyway with work and the gym.

 

Solid proposal, far more detailed than mine, i. I was just lookin' for a hangin' judge to, once 'n for all, end arguments that go no place.

 

I agree with GP actually. John Garfield is one of the very few posters on here who doesn't seem to have an agenda.

 

perhaps thereshould be 3 judges then ther could be some disputed split decisions :yep

 

He is, but he hates H2H match ups.

Perhaps you could judge Monzon vs anyone?

I recommend Jo-Jo Guerra as one of the judges.