Georges "The Orchid Man" Carpentier

Discussion in 'Classic Boxing Forum' started by yaca you, Aug 31, 2010.


  1. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010
    This content is protected

    Total Matches: 109 bouts
    Record: 88(57)-14-6 (1 ND)
    Height: 5′ 11½
    Weight class(s): Flyweight - Heavyweight
    Born: 1894-01-12 in Lens, Pas-de-Calais, France
    Death: 1975-10-28
    Nationality: French
    Stance: Orthodox



    Perhaps this should be in the European forum.


    Ok so I was watching some Jack Dempsey fights today and his mega fight the original "fight of the century" with Carpentier (first million dollar gate from which dempsey got paid $300,000 Carpentier $200,000, the purchasing power today would be in the millions about 3 2/3 and 2 1/2 million us dollars respectively ) was huge deal. they built a boxing ring for this event and over 90,000 boxing fans were in attendance.

    Carpentier "campaigned in every weightclass from flyweight to heavyweight" is considered to be "the best European fighter ever."

    He started out in [ame="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Savate"]Savate[/ame] then later was introduced to boxing by his manager Francois Descamps, and began his career at Flyweight the young age of 14, in November 2, 1908 according to boxrec.

    Carpentier won the French Welterweight title in june 15 1911, by tko in the 16 round over Robert Eustache.

    ko'd Young Joseph for the European welterweight title in october 23rd, 1911.

    In February 2nd, 1912 he he defeated Jimmy Sullivan for the European middleweight title.

    Carpentier then won the European light heavyweight title in February 19th, 1913 when he scored a second-round knockout of Bandsman Dick Rice.

    he became the European heavyweight champion with a 4th round stoppage over Bombardier Billy Wells in December 8th, 1913

    After beating Ed Gunboat Smith by disqualification in July of 1914 (Carpentier was hit while he was down) he was supposedly the #1 contender for Jack Johnsons Heavyweight World title.

    10 days after his victory over smith he fought once more then he joined the French Air Force in that same year and served as a observation pilot. Was decorated twice and popularized as an national hero. He never fought Jack Johnson.

    His military enlistment would extend five years and his return fight was on july 19, 1919 for the European heavy weight title.

    later he battled jack dempsey 2 years later in on july 2nd 1921 at Boyle's Thirty Acres, in Jersey City, New Jersey. he was seen as the more popular fighter of the two at that time because of his war record and that Dempsey was considered by many to be a "draft dodger". he was ko'd in 4 rounds by the Mannassa Mauler he was outweighed by 16 lbs and by the end of the fight was battered and blooded and reportedly suffered a broken thumb.

    Before his fight with dempsey in '21 he ko'd Battling Levinsky for the light heavyweight world title October 12th 1920 in 4 rounds. defended it against Ted Kid Lewis in the 1st round, but lost the title to Battling Siki by ko in the 4th.

    The Orchid Man, was also a referee for some boxing matches during and after his career including the world title bout between Jack Johnson and Frank Moran in June 1914, he last bout he refereed was in 1949.

    Georges "The Orchid Man" Carpentier was Inducted in the International Hall Of Fame in 1991

    Most of what I wrote can be found at the bio section of the Boxrec website

    The Ring website has "the best of all time A-Z" has it Ezzard Charles then the five others that were considered (Tony Canzoneri, Cassius Clay, Marcel Cerdan, Julio Cesar Chavez and Billy Conn) no offense to another french great Marcel Cerdan, even though Cerdan had more body-hair than Georges Carpentier, he should at least be considered the better of the two right?:yep

    I wonder how the Classic forum feels about Carpentier?

    I wonder how many of you would consider him to be a top 20 p4p canidate?
     
  2. klompton

    klompton Boxing Addict banned

    5,667
    39
    Jul 6, 2005
    overhyped and overrated
     
  3. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010
    not that many of you didnt know about Carpentier already, but I knew nothing about him except he fought dempsey until the other day.

    hearing he moved from flyweight to heavyweight was the thing that caught my attention.

    it is possible that I just got carried away with it all....


    I got a question, why do you think so few weights are listed through most of carpentier's career on boxrec they will list the titles he took but not the amount they weighed ?

    I read that his career might have been started at a higher wieght bantam I think.

    I also wonder how much weight he was giving up to some of his opponents.

    anyway here are some vids

    [ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k2mXqc1uLKk[/ame]

    he sure hits hard and is fast, but he seems to be wild at times and he pays for it here.

    exiting fight.

    [ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CI03W2_El68[/ame]

    he just has so much power
     
  4. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010
    ok................

    you being serious man, why is that?
     
  5. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    399
    Jan 22, 2010
    Wrong picture above...That is Tommy Loughran you posted above,
    and not Georges Carpentier !!!
     
  6. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010

    hot damn! thanks burt.:pwned

    *fixed*

    I liked that picture too.
     
  7. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    399
    Jan 22, 2010
    They were both good looking guys,,,
     
  8. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010
    so burt what do you say about Mr Carpentier?

    do you agree with klompton that he was "overhyped and overrated"?

    the vids I posted didnt make him out to be the most reserved, textbook type of fighter, but he had speed, power and fought in almost every weightclass their was at the time.
     
  9. TheGreatA

    TheGreatA Boxing Junkie Full Member

    14,241
    152
    Mar 4, 2009
    klompton's words carry a lot of weight, regardless of how he presented them, as he has probably researched Carpentier more than anyone else on this forum. Try and find some of his old posts about Carpentier, they're worth a read.

    http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=127769&page=2
    http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/showthread.php?t=210359&page=2

    I do think that Carpentier was overrated in his own time, he came up short against the very best, but nowadays he doesn't get a mention even among the great light heavyweights. He has been nearly forgotten about despite the great fame and popularity he enjoyed in his prime.

    As a fighter he wasn't the best technician, though he occasionally showed his boxing skill when not focused on simply throwing right hand bombs. He had speed and power as well as grit, best shown in the fight against Gene Tunney where he absorbed a brutal beating.
     
  10. mattdonnellon

    mattdonnellon Boxing Junkie Full Member

    8,589
    1,848
    Dec 2, 2006
    I Know that Klompton, who knows the period getter than most, doesent rate him at all, and this gives me food for thought. but based on his efforts v Klaus and Papke(as a youth), the wins over the British Heavyweights plus the Gunboat affair, and especially a fight not mentioned in the piece above, his fight v Jeannette, he was good. I have next day ringside reports of the Jeannette fight which had Carp a clear winner of that.
    Not the best European ever by a long shot but tough, capable with a really good right-hand.His auto-bio is available free on-line, interesting read.
     
  11. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010
    thank you Great A, I will.

    I simply wanted to find out more about him after watching his fight with dempsey, he carried so much power all while moving up in weight.

    klompton, I was reading some of your old posts, it is interesting what you say of georges being filmed to the extent he was even on youtube (some posted by non other than great A)
    when you take into account that they both fought in about the same era harry greb and carpentier, one has fights to be viewed and one does not.

    Your old posts are very helpful klompton and gives alot of context to the dates and numbers I posted.:thumbsup

    why is it that you have so much information on Carpentier?
     
  12. klompton

    klompton Boxing Addict banned

    5,667
    39
    Jul 6, 2005
    A CLEAR winner? Hardly. A close winner maybe, a draw maybe, or a loser (which was what happened) but as stated in several previous posts in relation to this fight Carpentier was the clear sentimental favorite and we all know that in close fights this can count for a lot of dissent.
     
  13. klompton

    klompton Boxing Addict banned

    5,667
    39
    Jul 6, 2005

    Because I have all of the films of him which are known to exist (and several which arent "known" to exist ;) ) and Ive done a lot of research on him because like you I was once very interested in how this young man could develop in a country that until the arrival of several notable Americans was fairly devoid of boxing talent.

    As I have stated in several previous posts Carpentier's effect on the popularization of Boxing throughout Europe was enormous, monumental in fact and for that he should be remembered and get a lot of credit. His popularity in Europe was greater than that of Dempsey, Louis, and Marciano combined.

    This is why there is so much smoke that needs to be looked through to get to the heart of Carpentiers true abilities and accomplishments. People also need to realize that boxing, particularly in continental Europe during this time was part sporting event and part theatre. This is an aspect that we look down upon in the United States even back then, calling pre-arranged fights "burlesque." People wanted to come watch Carpentier, they didnt care who he was fighting or how he was winning, even if it was suspicious, just as long as Carpentier was on the marquee and he was winning.

    Its very similar to German boxing in 1990s and early 2000s where a succession of German promoted fighters drew large audiences to watch them win fights regardless of how ridiculously fixed they might be. It was more pageantry than sport.

    Carpentier appeared in many of these events which have since been taken at face value when in fact he was a gravvy train, an exhibit that could generate enormous sums of money, in order to continue to the gravvy train rolling the illusion of his greatness had to be maintained. Therefore you see fixed fights, fights against sub par opponents billed as major events etc used to maintain to his stature and yet basically everytime he stepped up he was beaten pretty handily UNLESS something was going on behind the scenes such as the Gunboat Smith fight, Battling Levinsky fight, Willie Lewis, Etc.

    If you watch his fights, even his best performances with an objective eye you will see there is no variation in his style or approach from 1912 until 1925 (the range of years we have filme of him). He sticks out a long left as a range finder, throws his right hand (which was admittedly powerful) and then clinches waiting for the ref to reset them. Very predictable. He never developed beyond that and didnt have to because he was being protected. Not in matchmaking but by officials and promoters.


    So in short I give him all the credit in the world for popularizing the sport in Europe but he is not the fighter that Europeans nowadays give him credit for.
     
  14. burt bienstock

    burt bienstock Obsessed with Boxing Full Member

    18,285
    399
    Jan 22, 2010
    I am not an expert on carpentier, but what I have read and seen on film'
    Georges had a laser right hand kod ,Brtain' top hyeavyweights of that time
    Bomb. Billy Wells and Joe Beckett..Great right hand...
    Sidenote= many, many years ago ,a customer of mine who lived in
    Manhasset, Long Island...He was quite old then, and he had a picture of Carpentier on his wall...I asked him why, and he replied he was one of a few residents of Manhasset, who saw Carpentier train for the Dempsey fight in 1921...For what it's worth...b.b.
     
  15. yaca you

    yaca you Someone past surprise Full Member

    4,365
    56
    Jun 1, 2010
    well thats disappointing klompton, maybe he should have stuck with Savate instead of switching arts:D