P4P Top 10 Official Survey (Poll Closes October 27)

I'd be curious to hear your views on this, and I'd also be curious to know where you rank Lennox on your top 10 heavyweight list.

 

Sure you would. Those divisions don't date back that far.

In any case, just wanted to note that your prediction about diminishing returns as we went down the weight classes played out. With each new survey, the number of participants decreased.

I suspect already that it will go back up for this one.

Back to topic, I'm not sure if I'm happy with my own list.

:think

 

I was happy with every other list I made, and I think I only tweaked two of my lists after first posting them (the heavyweights and the flyweights).

These lists seem repetitive here, and I guess that was the case for all of them to some extent, but with a P4P list I was expecting a bit more variety.

I still maintain a guy like Hagler often gets penalized on these sorts of lists, because he spent his entire career at one weight class.

But the way I see it, I'm not really sure whether bonus points should be deserved for succeeding in multiple weight classes due to the traditional textbook definition of what P4P means.

At the same time, I was reluctant to include any heavyweights on my list which kind of goes against my prior point.

I need to give this more thought. I may radically change my list.

:smoke

 

That's a fair take, but doesn't this violate the spirit of the original meaning of the term "pound for pound"?