Did Kotelnik get robbed against Witter?

I'm watching the fight right now for the first time and want to see what General thinks.

[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OjUJCEom7zQ[/ame]


[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_edH40yXutk&feature=related[/ame]



[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bFCXYsQItpo&feature=related[/ame]



[ame]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyTticuFhAg&feature=related[/ame]

 

I have only watched the fight once when it was live on TV, but remember thinking Witter by a point or 2 but wouldnt have complained about a draw.

You should watch Kotelniks 2 fights with Mbaye

 

I heard about his fights with Mbaye I'll try to see if they're on yt aswell. Thanks for that.

 

Witter in a very close fight.

 

That's two for Witter. I wonder if anyone thinks Kotelnik won and if so hopefully they post on this thread. So far I have it like this:

Witter- 2,3
Kotelnik- 1

 

Witter won the first 5-6rounds with Kotelnik doing nothing and won the 12th.

 

Agreed, Kotelnik-Witter was too close too call it robbery(I scored 115-113 to Kotelnik). 2 fights with Mbaye were big time robberies.

 

Lol, I used the title as a way to catch people's attention. I'm still watching the fight so I can't consider it a robbery or not. So far 1 & 4 are for AK, 2-3 are for Witter on my card.

 

haven't seen the fight in ages.but from what i can remember, it was a real close one that i had for witter by a point or two.

 

Maidana was robbed

 

Witter- 2,3,6
Kotelnik- 1,4,5,7,8,9,10,11
Even- 12

Winner- Andreas Kotelnik 117-112

Witter fought too negatively later on in the 8th and on with his clinching he and should’ve followed up on his success going to the body like he did in the 6th round. Kotelnik is VERY hard to look great against and the only guy I thought looked very good against him was Khan. Not a robbery but I just went with the more calm guy in Kotelnik. Witter should’ve been more focus but instead he looked a little frustrated trying to get through that tight guard. Again, not a robbery my title was just meant to catch attention. I love Kotelnik I’m a fan but I let my bias out of scoring like usual. The wide margin on my card is abit misleading lol but this fight could’ve gone either way though Witter was fighting too negative for my taste and that’s probably what swayed me to have this big margin. Also, Kotelnik seemed to be landing the cleaner shots in the later rounds and just landing more in general. As much as I’m a fan of Devon too, I still can’t believe people thought he was going to knock AK out.

 

That's a close fight too that could've gone either way.

 

I had Witter just taking it by a couple if I recall

 

Certainly robbed against Alexander.

 

I can't argue with that especially with me judging for effectiveness. I guess if someone judged on purely aggression they could have it for Alexander. Personally I had it for Kotelnik even before I became a fan of his. On the night of the fight I was a DA fan only but watching more AK made me a fan of him too.