:think On the surface this sounds like a good idea. One world champion , best fighting the best and all that. BUT to me it's a bad idea. He wants Golden Boy to control the sport as a whole (at least in the US). To control the HBO dates and to control all the fighters. He wants them to be a promoter/sanctioning body rolled in to one like the UFC. That to me wouldn't solve boxing's problems. Why should Golden Boy be trusted to run the sport? If you have one company controlling the sport it could actually lead to more corruption, some fighters could get frozen out of the picture. Look at the UFC, if a non-UFC fighter wants to prove he's the best by fighting the top UFC fighter in his division he has to sign away all kinds of options and rights to get the fight. Say Golden Boy achieve this boxing 'utopia' in the States and Frank develops a star in the UK. Now Frank wants to match this fighter with the Golden Boy's top fighter but they won't allow it to happen unless the fight takes place on a Golden Boy card, overseen by Golden Boy with Golden Boy officials and everything else. In addition to all this he has to give options away. Now how would that be beneficial for boxing? I realise that in reality Oscar's plans stand little chance of coming to fruition but the fact that he;s even discussing it and admitting this is what GBP aim to achieve is a little disturbing for me. Your thoughts? *if you click on the link Oscar also talks about other stuff. This is just a part of a lengthy interview.
I agree that there you be one unified sactioning body, but it should be independant from any promoter to avoid the problems you listed. It should be a non-profit organisation that is funded by the sport. Very similar to our FA in football.
Boxing needs unity alright, but I doubt GBP signing up all the talent is going to be the way it happens. Sure Top Rank at the moment probably have a far stronger stable of fighters (I might be wrong). There's tons of promoters in the US besides them, plus what about the UK, Germany, Japan?
Exactly. A unified FIFA like body would help but it would need to be independent. You can't have a promoter running the sport like the UFC.
I think boxing needs the UFC business model. GBP have been practicing it for a while now. They are simply trying to embrace it more.
From Oscar's perspective, he's absolutely right. It would encourage fighters to fight more often, it would mean guys that are entertaining would get more dates and there'd be less nonsense over fighting the champ. But practically, it's a terrible idea. A commissioning body should have the sport's interests in mind, independent from promoters' preferences. They should make decisions that benefit the sport, the fighters and the paying audience. There's no shock that this is why Oscar wanted The Ring along with it's ratings. It's like a little sanctioning body and, slowly, if GBP become the dominant force in the sport, it'll be Ring titles rather than the WBC, WBA or IBF.
I'll run it for a mere 8 figures. Rob can do the rankings (he seems to enjoy it) Rooq can be matchmaker, Boxing girl can be office skirt and Mr VIP can be fluffer!!!
oscar might mean well but his idea is a pipe dream.it has obvious flaws that you mentioned.Also it is impossible to control all the fighters the boxing market is too open to do it.if oscar really wanted one belt he would have his fighters just fight under one belt
Realistically we aren't getting an independent body to run things so I think this is the best way forward but will only ever have limited success because the stars in boxing are too big. In mma so far a GSP or Brock Lesnar type who has established themselves as a star and a draw in the UFC hasn't left and tried to market themselves on PPV but in boxing if Floyd Mayweather wants to promote himself he can and can be somewhat successful
It's all well and good wanting to copy the UFC model - it'd certainly be better for the fans - but it seems to me that basically Dana White struck gold with it and the UFC is a bit of a one off. He got there first when MMA was first coming to people's attention, and because they pay more than anywhere else he can rule it very belligerently and force fights to be made. I don't think it could work like that with boxing because there are already some powerful people with stables of big name fighters which make decent money. It's worth noting that MMA promotions which aren't the UFC aren't immune to the type of bull**** we get as boxing fans. I'm no expert but isn't Fedor v Overeem basically a carbon copy of Floyd v Pac?
For years everyone wanted him to fight couture but it never happened. The same thing does happen just to a lesser extent!!!