Most controversial decisions or fights to close to call

Taylor v Chavez? Doesn't get more controversial than that!

 

This content is protected

 

But how? I've seen this fight twice (once live, once youtube) and I find it hard to score anything for Valuev let alone have him winning by a landslide. Haye does very little but he connects quite well whereas Valuev is perhaps a little more active but he doesn't hit ****!? Haye went virtually untagged through that fight the only punishment having received being a broken hand while trying to crack Valuev's chin.

Haye does little, Valuev does absolutely nothing. I don't remember one clean shot Valuev landed.

**** fight on top of that.

 

Yep, I know, seen it more than any other fight.
I never gave Barrera a 10-8 rd in rd 12 tho because it wasnt a knockdown but I did give him that rd 10-9, he did more IMO.
Check out fights 2 & 3, not as great but well worth watching.

Ps. I gave Morales 8 rds in the 2nd fight & 6 rds in the 3rd fight.

:good

 

The only clear win for either man was fight 2 which Morales won clear.... but to each their own judgement I suppose.

 

Wasnt a decision tho.... Chavez broke him down, knocked him out & ruined him for life.

This one doesnt qualify here.

 

Mmmm... interesting, seems Leonard has an edge on the votes just as he did that very night.
I scored 7-5 Leonard, great & underrated fight IMO.

 

you seem to know how to score a fight Im very impressed look foward to ur Collazo vs Berto scores hey do Martinez vs Williams and give me ur score also Kessler vs Froch and Calzghe vs Hopkins also Hopkins vs Taylor 1&2 Mosely vs Mora, Cotto vs Mosely

 

I completely agree :good

Valuev didnt do ****. Haye won fair and square, even though it isnt a fight I would want to watch again. Just like you I watched it live and on youtube, and both time I had Haye winning clearly.

 

Ben-Rabah and Urango.

Ben-Rabah clearly won that fight by a couple of rounds to only get robbed blindly.:-(

 

Let's not forget that race plays a huge factor in calling a fight controversial.

 

Hatton Colazzo

 

Same here.