Where do you guys rate the Klits?

Funky Robots can not be ranked.

I have them in Robot for Robot rankings 1,2 places.

 

V.K. # 7

W.K. # 13

:deal

MR.BILL:hat

I have "Holy & Tyson" in at #'s 8 and 9 with "Liston and Frazier" tying for 10th place... I think Holy and Liston would pose tough fights for V.K. due to their style and good boxing skills, but V.K. would eat Tyson and Frazier alive...
:good:scaredas:

 

Oh... And none of this horse**** that Jimmy Young would beat the K-brothers in a time machine... That's total bollocks... Young would be reduced to a human punching bag by either brother by round 6...
:yep:hi:

MR.BILL:rasta

 

i got VK over Frazier and Tyson H2H as well.

 

Top 100 for sure

 

everyone in Bert Sugar's 100 Greatests are above the Klitschko's, for now

 

Burt Sugar's list of ATG heavies has raised several eyebrows in the past...:admin

I'm sorry, but while dude's like "Charles and Tunney" were great all around boxers, they would not do well with many of the post 1960 heavies in a time machine...

MR.BILL:hat

 

Wlad i would say could be 10 but vitali not in the top 20. i dont understand why people match them up like they are the same talent. Wlad will destroy Vitali, only thing you cant account for is the psych aspect of him being the little brother not being able to beat the bigger brother.

 

Vitali beats the **** out of Wlad. Can you imagine how terrified Wlad would be? Watch him against the likes of Chagaev!

 

Depends if it's on a H2h or a career basis. H2H I'll put them both near the top 10.

Careerwise, I'd put V.K. in the top 20 range and W.K. in the 15-20 range.

 

thats fine, you can believe that. on the other hand, Bert Randolph Sugar tends to be one of the most relevant sources out there. that alone should make a fair arguement.

 

when you make an ATG list the only thing that matter are accomplishments like number of title defenses, wins against HOF and other ATG. Klit brothers don't have any wins against other HOF or ATG for the time being. Vitaly fought one and lost. They have long title runs so they should make it to the HOF one day. If I should rate them ATG for the HW division they should be between 15 and 20. P4P they will never make the top 100 for obvious reasons

 

I have both just outside my top 10. It's hard to rank them any higher as nether have been undisputed champion. Maybe Wlad can crack my top 10 one day if he can unify all the titles once Vitali retires.

 

No need to rate them at this time. We can wait until they retire.