Would you classify Floyd as ATG if he is an all-time coward?

Floyd is definitely not a coward but he definetely makes a lot of "business" moves in choose his opponents. Then again, pretty much every single fighter on top does...some more than others though.

 

Floyd fought the legitimate WW champion, Pac didn't. That's all History is interested in as far as 2010 goes.

 

Yes

 

Technically he is promoted by his own company "Mayweather Promotions" but he still needs Oscar for his big paydays.

 

Floyd did agree to that outrages demand of 10 million per pound over weight, and that was before Manny was ask to take a drug test. So what's the real deal about taking some drug test if you have nothing to hide. Twice the fight was not made for the same reasons on Pac behalf. Any other fighter would of jumped at the opportunity, hell i'm not a boxer and I would of jumped at the opportunity.

 

Floyd is a once-in-a-lifetime Boxer.

(You know that i love you Floyd, and i know you love me too, sometimes we just have a different opinion)

Your Marry

 

a fighter who habitually ducks the toughest competition while parading himself as the best fighter of all time, is a COWARD. and the cowardice of Duckweather will supercede any of his other accomplishments.

 

nah the all time coward is the guy that claims to love boxing but never even stepped between the ropes.

 

100% yes

6 time world champion, 5 different weight classes.

Beat a prime castillo, coralles, de la hoya, hatton, mosely

His resume is excellent, if he fights pacquiao or not his legecy is cemented as an ATG

 

History will also tell us Spinks beat Ali.

What Floyd did with Mosley was great, but due to the circumstances to make that fight happen, I would hardly use that fight as a good argument for showing PBF's balls. Mosley said it himself, PBF was forced into that situation, it was an un-duckable fight. PBF wanted no part of Mosley, neither did Manny to be fair.

 

is this sarcasm...i have to ask because some people on here are actually serious with some of these ******ed posts.....but im on the fence here with this post....i'll give u the benefit of the doubt and say its sarcasm

 

Mayweather goes down in history as the black Calzaghe, only with an even shittier resume.

 

Luke you're full of **** here. PBF's resume shits on Calzaghe's it's not even up for debate.

 

Oh, but calzaghe beat hopkins and RJJ!!!

Oh, but floyd beat DLH and corrales! Give me a ****ing break.

Black Calzaghe.

 

isn't floyd-mosley also an in-house? and looking back to floyd's last 4 fights, it was all in-house. even oscar paid for floyd's behalf when floyd weight above the 144 catchweight against the marquez-floyd in-house fight. at least pac has fought oscar and hatton in his last 4 fights which are not in-house.