How did you all score the Jose luis Castillo vs. Floyd mayweather Jr. 1 fight?

Damn BB, you couldn't use the search function to see the million of threads dedicated to the scoring of this fight?

 

floyd by a point or two (havent seen it since last december)...with that being said, i understand anything from 8-4 floyd to 7-5 castillo.

 

No problems my Adobo brother. I'll rewatch this fight right now and come back to this thread. Whats funny is that my score is always different each time I watch this fight.

 

I have not scored it but could have gone either way, I thought that Castillo, just edged it.

The rematch was one of Floyds best wins.

 

I had Mayweather winning the first 5 rounds.

Castillo then on my card wins 5 out of the next 7.


Had Castillo not been timid early on and gotten accustomed to Mayweather's speed a little earlier, he'd have won that fight.
.....but he got going to late imo, and Mayweather took it on my card 7-5.

 

Thats the thing about this fight.....if you dont score on paper and jot down every round, you'll likely come out with the impression that Castillo was robbed, as he pretty much had his way past the 6th round.


It was close no doubt, but you have alot of people in forums like this convinced that Castillo got shafted.

 

I had Floyd by close decision upon initial viewing.

 

That exactly.
I've scored it 4 times, my results being: 6-5-1 Mayweather, 6-6 draw, 7-5 Mayweather, and 7-4-1 Mayweather. The perfect modern example of a super close fight. Mayweather won the re-match convincingly.

 

One things for sure, floyd is not unbeatable, it only takes a split second and bang! The games over1

 

Over1 wtf!

 

Castillo fairly close but an obvious win. Void ran from Pac to save his arse!

 

Yet there are still plenty of posters here who will go to their grave claiming JLC wasn't shot when Ricky beat him.

 

Castillo won the fight, it's obvious.