Rate me as a poster

doug.ie · Oct 31, 2010

where's burt in the rankings ?....proper guru is burt.

TommyV · Oct 31, 2010

doug.ie said: ↑

where's burt in the rankings ?....proper guru is burt.
Click to expand...

Pachilles will claim he's biased towards old-timers, which will penalize him in the rankings.

choklab · Oct 31, 2010

I would say most of the regulars are all good even the ones who get a bit catty.

PetethePrince · Oct 31, 2010

Pachilles said: ↑

In the Lounge you would crack a top 50, no doubt. In the classic, im afraid to say you are lacking in, well...class. You've kind of fallen into the 'snob' category of posters who spend more time criticising other posters posts than putting your own out for scrutiny, making cookie cutter P4P lists, following fads(MW Duran, Holmes jab etc) and going against the grain(ironically at the same time as everyone else is). And correcting spelling mistakes.

Behind all the posturing it is clear you knowledgable, though. And i see no reason why you shouldnt make the top 75 on longevity and popularity alone

GPater, Greggie Greg Patterson, where do i start:huh

You are a very gifted poster, Pater. Observational skills that rival my own and knowledge that rivals posters 50 years your senior. There is one thing that lets you down massively though. You try too hard. All that knowedge stuffed inside that still developing cranium of yours. Youthful vigor only worsens your issue and you clearly lack clarity. As gifted as you are, your brain no doubt, is telling you that the kangaroo jab of Fitzsimmons is awful, but at such an impressionable age, the teeny bopper obsession of fitting into the sub culture is making you lie, and perhaps see things with warped vision. I feel your opinions are heavily influenced by your peers, the wrong peers, and that you've been fed to the sharks very young and tender. But you will no doubt grow into a great poster with tremendous longevity and knowledge which will no doubt see you into the top 5, perhaps, in time.

As of now though i'd say any lower than top 25 would be underrating you. Top 10 or higher would be overrating you
Click to expand...

Great stuff, even if it's not 100% of the truth it certainly has half-truths.

Personally, I think you're underrated Bokaj. Where's Mr. magoo, Duodenum, and My2Sense? And if you didn't forget them, how far did they come from cracking the top 15? I think they're both cracking posters.

Obviously I get a slight bit more jollies of your list than others as I'm seemingly a P4P Juggernaut, kind of like the kid who gets everything he wants at Christmas. I do want to say you're overrating me but it is me after all, and who am I to question your judgment? I'd be arrogant to do so either way. I'd probably say the same about your #2 as well. As for Old Fogey, isn't he the most unemotional poster in the classic section? I do see the Terminator... he just churns out the facts and lets everyone else argue on about them.

Log in or Sign up

Rate me as a poster

doug.ie 'Classic Boxing Society' Full Member

TommyV Loyal Member banned

choklab cocoon of horror Full Member

PetethePrince Slick & Redheaded Full Member