better win..floyd versus shane..manny-margo??

That's why I said "may" :good

 

38 years old, coming off a 14 month layoff and anybody who watches that fight and is honest can see that Mosley is shot to ****, reflexes gone and incapable of pulling the trigger.

Yes Floyd beat Margarito and Pacquiao beat Cotto who beat Mosley (a better version than Floyd fought) and Margarito who beat Cotto. Manny has also destroyed common opponents far worse (De La Hoya, Hatton) ABC logic is foolish. Reality is that Floyd's win vs a shot 38 year old coming off a 14 month layoff is the biggest accomplishment he has in 5 years in the WW division, that's beyond pathetic.

 

At the times of the debated fights:
Rankings by The Ring...
Mosley: #3 P4P fighter, #1 welterweight
Margarito: unranked by anyone in a top 50 P4P list, unranked by anyone at any weight class

Anyone who voted Pac over Margarito, please, please explain to me why.

 

Good point atsch

But Mayweather over Mosley for me.

 

floyd vs shane.

shane was the best in the division plus sparked margo in his last meaningful fight. no brainer.

 

Cotto, Mosley, Margarito are all in a triangle of W's

That in mind, (barring all the old age, shot, plaster, bum, misc bull****) in both fights both shane and margo were on the verge of getting KO'ed but the difference was Margo got bloodied up and a busted eye.

So I'll say Pac-Marg

 

Manny Pacquiao "He caught me with a body shot in the sixth round that hurt me very bad....I was lucky to survive the round." So Manny's better cause it happened in the 6th round instead of the 2nd?

 

because he had 17 pounds slowing him down duh and the fight took place last night and I can still remember what ahppened and Floyd's an ******* who counts his money on youtube and makes fun of Emanuel so he sucks:nut

 

Mayweather's ruination of Mosley was the more meaningful fight.

 

Floyd beat the World Welterweight Champion & P4P#4 coming from an even more impressive win over Margarito, who wasn't the same ever after... your judgement has to be really clouded to put Saturday's win over Mayweather's, who in all assholeness clearly outperfomed Pacquiao this year. No credit taken away from Pac, just keepin' it real. The Vacationer fought a goddamn top5 P4P-er for a lineal title a dominated utterly.

 

anytime a guy beats a great regardless of age is a better win. The Shane win is much better. Shane will always be on Mayweather's record. So will Margarito, but Margarito was destroyed by Shane.

 

pacman vs marg... 38 yr old/ring rust/ off steroids = past prime mosley

 

Margarito was better last night, than Mosley currently is.

I know Mosley battered Margarito but that was in no way the best Margo. That win clouded all the doubts people should have had over Mosley, who hasn't looked his best since the first Vargas fight. He's been fading for a long time and the version Mayweather beat was shot.