ATG: Who Ranks Higher? Manny Pacquiao or Sugar Ray Leonard?

meant to pick leonard. even though personally i believe Leanords in ring accomplishments are slightly overrated i still believe hes ahead of Pac in ATG ratings.

plus every time i watch hagler-leonard i have a different winner.

 

pac is the easy answer!! srl ducks pryor and let hagler gets old. pac has achieved more!

 

Would Harold Weston beat Cotto and Margarito with no problem? Would Bruce Curry?

Half of the people on this board just know names, have no idea of what the actual fighter was like. Kneejerk responses like this are just annoying. At this point in Pac's career this is a very legit question to ask, regardless of what you think the answer is.

 

...

 

Omg what garbage poll results, that's absolutely disgusting.

 

You know, winning fighter of the year is meaningless, beeing p4p number one is also meaningless when judging one guys greatness. Winning 8 titles is not meaningless but you have to see that he did win 8 belts not championships, you have to see that he won one belt in a catchweight fight, you have to see that half of those divisions are ******* divisions and titles there aren´t worth as much. I like Manny but keep it real.

 

This is why I can't take pac fans seriously. Pac is a great fighter. But beating cotto, hatton, clottey and Margarito collectively is not even as good as beating Benitez let alone Duran, Hearns and Hagler. This **** is ******ed Pac fans stop it:-(

 

being a fan of Pac means you like Pac, not his fans. you can be a pacfan but have different opinion to other pacfans.






btw, SRL still ranks higher than Pac.

 

Definately, without any shadow of doubt, ranks much higher than floyd... but pac hasnt fought a WW or LMW at the top of their game!!

 

SRL, comp is head and shoulders above Pacmans, seriously.

 

Yea you're right. I mean Morales, Barrera, De la hoya were in their primes when they fought Pacquiao right? Stfu you bandwagon Pacquiao fan. Hagler maybe past his prime but he still was a great fighter in which before his fight vs Leonard, mostly everyone thought Leonard was going to get killed cause he hasn't fought in 3 or 4 years and was coming back from an serious eye injury.

 

The way you're saying you think Pacquiao ranks higher then Leonard right? Behonest.

 

i have srl top 5-10ish, while pac 17-22ish

 

Even if he did fight a WW of LMW on top of his game. You telling me that any WW or LMW out there compares to the top names of Leonard resume? This ain't pac's fault he can only fight the guys that are currently out there. But no way does beating Cotto and Margarito compare to beating the likes of Hearns.

 

not at all!!! leonards resume is far better than pacs!!! thats why i voted for leonard!!! :yep