Manny Pacquiao's Top 15 Wins..

If Cotto and Oscar are his 2nd and 4th best wins, it kind of makes a mockery of all this "top 10 all time" stuff doesn't it?

I'd rate Barrera 1 and Marquez 2. Anything after that are pretty equal

 

1.Barrera 1
2.Marquez 2
3.Margarito
4.Cotto
5.Morales 2
6.Hatton
7.Sasakul
8.Clottey
9.Oscar
10.Ledwaba
11.Barrera 2
12.D Diaz
13.Larios
14.Solis
15.Morales 3

 

I just mean, take Ezzard Charles who was 12 all time, on ESPN's last list

His top 5 wins would probably read:

1: Joe Louis (peak)
2: Joe Walcott (peak)
3: Archie Moore (peak)
4: Joe Maxim (peak)
5: Elmer Ray (peak)

You can argue the top 3 would be in the top 20 best of all time?

That's why I never buy people trying to fit Floyd and Manny in any top 20.

Top 20, you need to have faced at least 3-4 of the top 50 fighters of all time

 

Eder Jofre.

 

Hmmm, good point. But I don't think Jofre is a banker for top 20

One or two lists maybe. Not every list

 

Ya that's not a top 10 resume

 

Louis wasnt in his peak when he lost to Charles what the hell are you talking about.

And his wins over Bivins,Burley or Marshall are better than his win over Ray.

 

I agree. I aint trying to be cruel. Floyd's isn't either

You just look at everyone in the top 15.

They've all faced at least 3-4 of the top 50 fighters of all time.

Some of them, have faced 5-6

 

Louis was 50-1 when he fought Charles, and hadn't lost in 14 years!?

As for Ezzard Charles 5 top wins, I'd say 5th place is a matter of debate.

Let's just accept he beat a lot of HOFers.

Charles 5th best win surpasses Floyd or Manny's number 1

 

Both good points. Perhaps you are right about Morales, I may reconsider that one. And Oscar is of course an underrated win, considering 18 out of 20 The Ring experts picked him to win.

 

What are Duran's 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th best wins?

 

Don't.

 

I don't buy any win over Morales.

El Terrible was coming off a bad loss even when he beat Pacquiao.

2nd fight,he was losing to journeymen at that time