atsch For comparing Winky to Clottey. Winky is light years better than Clottey fool and is a ATG at 154.
p4p no doubt Pac would outpunch Winky enroute to a UD. Pac is way better than Fernando in which he struggled.
This is a hard pick. Winky had a hard jab, his main weapon, and a great defense. He did great vs. boxers and punchers, but where he never did that great were with volume punchers. Because Winky stood there and take the fighter's best punches, fighters like Williams and Pacman would be the worst style matchup for Winky. His achilles heel. Winky even had the controversial win over Sam Soliman many thought Soliman won. Winky doesn't have Mosley's power, but he did take powerpunches alot better than Mosley ever did and that's saying alot. I'm not counting Winky out, I think a prime Oscar and Mosley have a better chance to beat Pacman by outboxing him, but Winky was the type who outboxed you by standing right in front of you, blocking your best punches and then see if you could do the same when he returned the favor. I just think it's a bad style matchup for Winky.
Prime Winky didn't fight flat footed and could move in and out, obviously not like Pacman but he was much lighter on his feet than he is now. So he won't be a completely stationary target ala Clottey. I think this fight would come down to how Pacman can crack Winky's defense. If he stays right in front of Winky, he gets jabbed to death. So how well can he get to Winky from the side? Let's not forget that Winky fought much bigger guys like Hopkins and Taylor and took their punches. He's got a good chin. I think it would be a close decision either way.
Winky actually throws punches As for this matchup i don't know. Both in their prime are damn near unbeatable. Pac has the style, but Winky was so good
Pacquiao fans just ignore logic. There answer to any question with Pacquiao is: 1: He'll win 2: He has the perfect style for him. A quick question. What freaking fights are you referering to when you think Pacquiao has a good style for Winky freaking Wright? Stinkinig it up with Clottey, getting his ass handed to him by Marquez, struggling in the Barrera rematch? Any guy who can box with a bit of skill pushes Pacquiao hard. Gives him a tough fight HOF guys like Winky, at 154, beat him easily
Hahaha, man, I'm going to have to retire, until Pacquiao gets out of boxing, so you guys can find another idol, and start talking BS about ............MMA or the WWE Pacquiao's struggled in two many fights to even list Unbeatable? WTF Marquez did a pretty good job
Pacquiao don't fight anyone who can jab, anyone who can counter, or anyone who can fight tactically. If he did, he'd lose more. End of argument