You got a point. I guess based on that you could put him higher. I think Haye is better and would beat him, but FLoyd isn't number 1 even though he's better than PAcquiao
I find your list North-American-centric (the Holy Trinity of Dawson, Ward and Williams) Mayweather above Manny is utter bollocks of course. Maybe before Manny beat Margo, Floyd had just crept ahead, but now it's obvious that Manny is the clear #1. The list is generally okay, but there are many discrepancies. Do you seriously have Tim Bradley 30 places above Amir Khan? And Kelly Pavlik above Carl Froch, Berto, Khan, Darchinyan & Arthur Abraham? And Kessler is too low.
Kessler has beaten several Top 10 ranked SMW's, picked up a few belts, and had a good win over Froch in his last fight. From the OP's perspective Paul Williams brutal KO defeat hasn't budged him out of the Top Ten so there is a big disparity between Williams & Kessler's ranking, and also Kessler & Ward's. The difference between those fighters is minimal. It seems that Williams, Ward and Dawson get extra points for being American. As does Bradley. Because the absolute worst aspect of this list is Bradley's position in relation to Khan. The OP shows his true colours with that choice. And it damages any potential credibility that could have arisen from his selections.
1 - Pac 2 - Mayweather 3 - Martinez 4 - Wlad or JMM 5 - Jmm or Wlad ----------------- in no order, I think bot Adamek Haye deserve mention, Adamek was a light heavy..... and is competing at heavy and will be fighting Vitali shortly. Haye was a cruiser and is considered by most to be one of the top heavies around, but his lack of competition undermines his talent. --------------- the rest. Dont see how someone can think strongly enough of each persons ranking to feel comfortable posting an actual list once you get past 4 or 5 to be honest..... I cant even go past 5 because I dont feel the names I have to put in those slots warrant their position in all honesty. Too interchangeable with other fighters as well.
The one thing that really struck me was Roman Gonzalez at 40. I have him much higher. Much much higher. But then its all about opinion. But I disagree with that placement. a lot. But its all about opinion. But your wrong.
your placings of bradley, ward, and dawson is nothing short of disgraceful :dead:dead:dead i want you to tell me what these 3 fighters in their career have done to be ranked 15 places above former undisputed crusierweight champ and current wba champ david haye :think i also want to know why you've ranked them above cotto?
That's what I thought. I rate them all highly but they havn't actually done anything to be ranked that highly. Having all three above Cotto is bizarre.