Cotto? He got roughed up by C level Clottey. He barely beat a shot old Mosley which is his best win...Cotto's an HBO hype job. He should stick to fighting bums at 154lbs, Paul Williams would beat the **** out of him at 154 and Maravilla would put him in a coma, Cotto isn't a top guy at 154lb let alone top 15 p4p.
Froch below Dirrell and Pascal who he beat. Bradley in the top 10. Alexander in the top 20, both above Khan. Dawson over Pascal. and to top it all off you have pavlik in the list.
If you know the true essence of P4P, you would not put the 250 lbs Wlad that high. P4P is a hypothetical matchup between 2 fighters IF they were the same size and conventional wisdom says that a smaller fighter will only get better if he wre bigger. Kinda imagine a natural 6'5", 250 lbs Floyd Mayweather? P4P is not favorable towards heavy HWs like Wlad, Lewis, Vitali. But lighter skilled HWs like Ali and Tyson can easily rank very high.
1. Manny Pacquiao 2. Floyd Mayweather 3. Juan Manuel Marquez 4. Wladimir Klitschko 5. Sergio Martinez 6. Vitali Klitschko 7. Miguel Cotto ^This is the part of my list I'm certain about. 8. Juanma Lopez 9. Andre Ward 10. Tim Bradley 11. Amir Khan 12. Pongsaklek Wonjongkam 13. Paul Williams 14. Mikkel Kessler 15. Andre Dirrel 16. Arthur Abraham 17. Fernando Montiel 18. Nonito Donaire 19. David Haye/Lucian Bute 20. Carl Froch/Jean Pascal ^ These are the right names, but I'm not sure about the precise order.
Lol ok hater, I would try to prove it to you, but I don't wanna be giving out my information like that
Respect and thanks for posting. Very good top 22. No Segura though? Khan and Dirrell are the two I disagree with here on your list. Khan, whose top quality wins are against "not the same Barrera" Barrera, Kotelnik, and aging, last fight at 140 Paulie, does not stack up with guys you have him listed amongst. Let alone the one-minute bout where he got completely blasted away... by Breidis Prescott... Yeah. Fair enough though, December 11 will be the day where we find out whom is right.