Pac/May vs. Delahoya/Hatton/Marquez

Its not comparable, Floyd fought marquez at 147, oscar 154,hatton 147
Pac fought marquez but never above 135,oscar 147 and hatton 140.
But pac looked better because, he destroyed hatton at his natural weight while floyd had a late ko in his own division.

 

Floyd:

He fought a very dangerous Oscar and Manny didnt :deal

He fought a more controlled, undefeated hatton and Manny didnt :deal

He SCHOOLED Marquez and Manny couldnt :deal

 

Its not too comparable as they were all very different versions.

 

They both fought a past his prime Oscar. Only difference is Oscar thought he could still drop in weight against Manny.
However, let us not forget how Pac silenced the critics by not only beating ODLH, but by retiring him for good. This has a lot to do with Pac's skill as well.
I give the edge to Floyd on this one, albeit a small one.

******ed thinking.

More ******ed thinking.

Bottom line is they fought different versions of the fighters.

I'd say Pac faced the better JMM. If you don't recognize this then you need serious help.

It's hard to gauge how Hatton was when he fought Pac since he didn't seem to have been fazed at all by the loss to Floyd (his trainer at the time however, was questionable).
He also faced Pac at arguably Pac's peek (both division and time) thus the brutal KO.
You can argue that Hatton was not focused but I can say all day that Roach just knew his stuff and Pac executed his game plan splendidly.
I'll go as far into saying that even if Hatton had a strict game plan then, he'd still get brutally KO'd by Pac and in a much much more impressive way than Mayweather ever will (who struggled HARD on the first half of the fight btw, against Pac it was simply pure domination).
And let us not forget that they fought at a weight class where Hatton was undefeated.
Of course you do understand that fighting above your natural weight class is disadvantageous to say the least.

 

Lets compare ali/foreman/frazier and norton while you're at it ****ing nitwit.

i dont know what **** they feed you down pacland but i want some.

 

Yes and no, styles make fights and different versions are either better or worse and it can be very significantly different versions.

 

floyd, period.

 

Pac

 

Nuff said. I would add that Hatton had a gameplan for Mayweather and followed it, against Pacquiao he seemed to just run in and hope to ship his punches.

But style wise, Pacquiao is more entertaining. Mayweather a better boxer. "hit and don't get hit"

 

hmmmm

Money fought a better version of ODLH (past prime but not weight drained) but Pac beat Oscar more convincingly


Pac fought a better version of JMM (not blown up) but Floyd has a more decisive victory.


Floyd beat an undefeated Hatton and knocked him out, Pac ktfo Hatton in 2 rds in his best weight.


I'd say this is a stupid question to answer because this does not prove anything.

... and I'm pretty much stupid replying on this thread.