the greater fighter, and higher on the ATG list Wilfredo Gomez or Joe Calzaghe?

Calzaghe, obviously. There's simply no comparison.

 

Obviously.

 

i think gomez takes this but not as clearly as one would think. they both dominated their divisions and beat respectable, but not always ATG fighters. gomez has a clear, brilliant win over an ATG in zarate and his victories over pintor and laporte are also very respectable. calzaghe had a similiar run, dominating a division without benefit of all time great fighters but never clear beat a brilliant fighter in their prime. His wins against jones and hopkins were either unconvincing or marred by how far they had fallen from grace. gomez i think was a better fighter than calzaghe but their respective rankings may not be as far apart as many (myself included) would like to think

 

Calzaghe never lost, Jorodz! EVER!

 

In ever, Jordoz. In ever!

 

Gomez takes this easily. He had better skills and fought better composition and not only that but has the better win in Zarate who was in his prime. Calzaghe wouldn't dream of facing someone as dangerous as Zarate:hey.

 

Tocker Pudwill, man. Tocker Pudwill.

 

Dude, Calzaghe beat Roy Jones and Bernard Hopkins...


END THREAD.

 

Sugar Tocker Pudwill was amazing. Also, Bangin' Branko Sobot.

 

LOL, this thread is something else. It's my much needed dose of sarcasm for the day.

 

I don't know anything about no Sarcasm but I know he ain't no Super Dragon Joe, mu****a! He probably ain't even top 50!

 

Gomez.

BTW this a borderline shommel thread

 

No, that would be Tocker Pudwill VS Roy Jones Junior at 168.

 

Calzaghe can't carry Gomez' jockstrap! Anyone who thinks otherwise can kiss where the sun don't shine lol.