Do you rank Bernard Hopkins higher than Floyd Mayweather in the ATG standings?

I do.

Hopkins fights younger, more dangerous opponents in his 40s than Mayweather does in his prime.

What's your call here? :bbb

 

Yup. His best wins trump any of Floyd's I think.

 

Whithout question. Not even debatable imo.

 

Higher. Mayweather better fighter in terms of peak and H2H (IMO), but Hopkins longevity and accomplishments are ridiculous.

 

Was prime Mayweather really a better fighter than the absolute peak Hopkins of 97-01, the guy who completely demolished peak Felix Trinidad, one of the most dominant and great middleweight champions of all-time?

I have my doubts.

 

He is also higher than Pac. Using your same logic.

 

Only a raving ***** would rank Floyd higher than Old Man River.

 

Bernard Hopkins.<-----

 

a few days ago in a same thread people had them close but b-hop slightly up, one draw later and he is way up, personally I have hopkins above mayweather, did yester do even more so today.

 

Yes i'd have him higher at present. I do think hopkins get's slightly overrated because of his longevity though

 

Hopkins getting a draw (BHop won) at age 45 against a Champ 18 years his younger is more respectable than Mayweather UD Marquez.

 

This age thing is bull****. If you ain't that good to begin with then age is irrelevant. Pascal was way over hyped since his victory against Chad.

 

Hopkins after last night ranks higher than any active fighter but Pac.

 

what does that tell you about dawson?

 

yes