Well it's your rankings so you can do what you want with them Rob. It's near impossible to fairly rank each division anyway especially when a large majority of fights are handpicked and boxers move up and down in weight so freely these days. I'd just do a round up of each division instead: Heavyweight: Genuine World Champion: Wladimir Klitschko Fighter of 2010: Wladimir Klitschko (beat Eddie Chambers, Samuel Peter) The 'should be' #1 contender: Vitali Klitschko or David Haye Cruiserweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Denis Lebedev (beat Alexander Alexeev / lost questionable decision against Huck) The 'should be' #1 contender: Marco Huck, Steve Cunningham or Denis Lebedev Light Heavyweight Genuine World Champion: Jean Pascal Fighter of 2010: Jean Pascal (beat Chad Dawson / questionable draw with Bernard Hopkins) The 'should be' #1 contender: Chad Dawson or Bernard Hopkins Super Middleweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Carl Froch (lost close decision away to Mikkel Kessler / beat Arthur Abraham) The 'should be' #1 contender: Andre Ward or Carl Froch Middleweight Genuine World Champion: Sergio Martinez Fighter of 2010: Sergio Martinez (beat Kelly Pavlik, Paul Williams) The 'should be' #1 contender: Felix Sturm Light Middleweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Miguel Cotto (beat Yuri Foreman) The 'should be' #1 contender: Miguel Cotto, Sergi Dzinziruk or Alfredo Angulo Welterweight Genuine World Champion: Floyd Mayweather Jr Fighter of 2010: Floyd Mayweather Jr (beat Shane Mosley) The 'should be' #1 contender: Floyd Mayweather or Manny Pacquiao Light Welterweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Amir Khan (beat Paulie Malignaggi, Marcos Maidana) The 'should be' #1 contender: Tim Bradley/Devon Alexander or Amir Khan Lightweight Genuine World Champion: Juan Manuel Marquez Fighter of 2010: Juan Manuel Marquez (beat Juan Diaz, Michael Katsidis) The 'should be' #1 contender: Humberto Soto or Miguel Acosto Super Featherweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Ricky Burns (beat Roman Martinez, Andreas Evensen) The 'should be' #1 contender: Mzonke Fana, Ricky Burns or Jason Litzau Featherweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Juan Manuel Lopez (beat Steven Luevano, Bernabe Concepcion, Rafael Marquez) The 'should be' #1 contender: Chris John, Juan Manuel Lopez or Yuriorkis Gamboa Super Bantamweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Ryol Li Lee (beat Poonsawat Kratingdaenggym) The 'should be' #1 contender: Toshiaki Nishioka or Royl Li Lee Bantamweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Abner Mares (drew Yonnhy Perez, beat Vic Darchinyan) The 'should be' #1 contender: Fernando Montiel/Nonito Donaire or Abner Mares/Joseph Agbeko) Super Flyweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Hugo Cazares (beat Nobuo Nashiro, Everado Morales, Alberto Rossel) The 'should be' #1 contender: Hugo Cazares, Tomas Rojas or Cristian Mijares Flyweight Genuine World Champion: Pongsanklek Wonjongham Fighter of 2010: Pongsanklek Wonjongham (beat Koki Komedo, Suriyan Por Chokchai) The 'should be' #1 contender: Daiki Kameda Light Flyweight Genuine World Champion: Giovani Segura Fighter of 2010: Giovani Segura (beat Ivan Calderon) The 'should be' #1 contender: Luis Alberto Lazarate or Ulises Solis Strawweight Genuine World Champion: vacant Fighter of 2010: Nkosinathi Joyi (beat Raul Garcia) The 'should be' #1 contender: Nkosinathi Joyi or Oleydong Sithsamerchai
At heavy I don't think Adamek is justified being ranked so high, nor chagaev. Solis should be higher. Andrade higher than Abraham at SMW? At LWW I'd probably put Maidana higher than Kotelnik too. Being a bit picky but meh
I know this is a little off topic but I see Manny Pacquiao titles at two different weights one of which is a WBO belt, how come they(The WBO) haven't stripped him like they did Sergio Martinez??
Lebedev should be above Huck if the point of these rankings is to actually make a legit list based on knowledge. If its just ranking people on 'official' results what does that achieve? Anyone can trawl boxrec for records and make a list, it would be more useful if there was input and discussion about things like that.
How come you have my Ajose Olusegun at number 14 in the LWW below Paul McCloskey. Ajose is undefeated and has won the WBF Intercontinental belt, the African Boxing Union title, the reigning Commonwealth champion and former British champion undefeated, unbeatable and current WBC number 1 contender, soon to defeat Ali Chebah in January 2011 in the final world title eliminator before contesting and finally winning the prestigious WBC belt won by greats such as the great Julio Cesar Chavez Senior.
I love you to baby. Merry XMAS. Have a great one and look forward vto great fights in 2011. Gotta a feeling that its going to be great year in boxing.