Rating Poochiao over Duran.

He/she is exactly that.

 

01. Henry Armstrong
02. Harry Greb
03. Sugar Ray Robinson
04. Sam Langford
05. Ezzard Charles
06. Bob Fitzsimmons
07. Willie Pep
08. Benny Leonard
09. Mickey Walker
10; Roberto Duran
11. Archie Moore
12. Joe Gans
13. Muhammad Ali
14. Barney Ross
15. Jimmy McLarnin
16; Joe Louis
17. Charley Burley
18. Terry McGovern
19. Sugar Ray Leonard
20. Tony Canzoneri
21. Barbados Joe Walcott

As long as he's not ahead of any of them. I haven't stretched my P4P list beyond that yet and to be honest, I really dont' care where he places after those names.

 

Theres no point mate, you honestly cant have a discussion with these kind of people. Any slight disagreement with them or small critisism of Pacquiao and they tell you that you hate him and just start rattling off names. I was told that I hated Pac because I called someone crazy for saying his fight with Plastarito was FOTY.

 

i rate how you dont feel you have to put ali at number 1 :good

 

You dont really like ali?

 

Get ****ed ALT.

I don't want to argue with this particular username...go login to another one and then I will "debate" with you.

 

Ali is a fantastic fighter with great achievements, but you can't discount the achievements of the likes of Walker, Duran, Gans, Moore etc, all of who have a case for being ranked above him.

Quite frankly, Ali can rank anywhere from where I have him now all the way up to 5 and I wouldn't have a problem with it whatsoever.

 

*******s all sort of merge into one big mess... there hard to tell apart with their bad grammer, minimal boxing knowledge, and their impulsively defensive remarks and insults.

 

Of course they would you idiot. They're all much bigger ATGs or very good fighters with a style advantage at higher weights than Pacquiao. I could easily say Duran would get schooled by prime Hopkins and Bute, Ward etc.

 

But Duran's 'prime' weight wasn't at 147 and you complained earlier that Mayweather fought Hatton at 147 because it wasn't Hatton's best weight.

Just for the record, I think Pacquiao would beat Duran at 147, but Duran still ranks higher p4p and would **** Pacquiao below 147.

 

Smokin' Joe is your favourite fighter too?!

You Magic are a God.

 

Its not either / or its both. Duran is one of the best and Pacquiao will be too by the time he's finished.

In terms of ring achievements, quality of opposition and high profile fights Pacquiao is already pretty close to Duran and he's still active.

Win, lose or draw I think Pacquiao would give Duran or any other all time great the fight of their life. You would likely demand to see a second and third fight, too.

Pacquiao would be an all time great if he retired tomorrow. However, lets hope he fights on a little bit longer than he probably should.

 

I'll tell you one thing man, Miguel Acosta would smash Pongsalek Wonjongkam to pieces.

 

Duran will always be lightyears ahead of pacquiao, if they fought in their primes duran would win and easily imo,
Manny has a lot of flaws and duran is one of the very few fighters who could expose manny and would do it well !