Who is Higher in the List of ATG? Tito Or Oscar?

Trinidad or De la hoya?

 

I voted Tito just based off the fight with Hopkins and their fight that ended up in draw, but honestly I don't care which one is higher. All I know is that its damn close.

Good thread.

 

Oscar. Ain't even close.

 

Could you explain?

 

Of course.

It really shouldn't need explaining, man.

 

Obviously it does. I mean thats the point of posting in a forum right.

 

Not that he rates oscar higher that I agree with but how its not even close.
I know oscar fought way tougher guys but he also lost most of those big fights.

 

Whoever you choose, it cant be by a far margin, i understand why people will side with both fighters

 

:good
Exactly my point.

 

Oscar continued to fight, taking on tough guys, winning and losing. Tito kind of disappeared, didn't test himself too much. I'd have to give Oscar the edge based on guts and effort.

 

I'm going to need you to watch his fights again seriously.

 

Actually they both have not been relevant since 2004, difference was Oscar being the cashcow and everyone wanted to fight him therefore he was still in big fights, he has guts though. That and him beating trinidad and mosley the second time in my eyes therefore puts him slightly higher, but not wayyyyy higher though.

 

Oscar's gold medal puts De La Hoya over Trinidad.

 

What does that have to do with his pro record? were not ranking audley harrison higher then holmes either.

 

Oscar's resume is full of him beating up smaller older men whom are one or two fights away from retirement and losing in big fights. I place them very close to one another somewhere behind Winky Wright.