Were Toney's best performances at mw better than B-Hop's at mw or Calzaghe's at smw?

Can anyone explain to me what relevance this post has to the thread-topic? :dead

 

Excellent post.

 

Let's see your proof Nunn was top 10 rated p4p then.

 

Yet another General Forum fanboy turd educated and owned in style:


http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/The_Ring_Magazine's_Annual_Ratings:_1990


He was official p4p#3 for year ending 1990, and Toney fought him in 1991.

:smoke

 

Where is Kessler in the p4p top 10 then??? :huh


http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/The_Ring_Magazine's_Annual_Ratings:_2005

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/The_Ring_Magazine's_Annual_Ratings:_2006

http://boxrec.com/media/index.php/The_Ring_Magazine's_Annual_Ratings:_2007



Let's stick to the facts from now on, shall we? :smoke

 

Fair enough mate, let's say Kessler was just generaly regarded as top 15 as well instead of top 10 (I had him in my top 10 at the time) Calzaghe beat Kessler more convincingly anyway imo because come from behind KO's are not always convincing and Toney never botherd to rematch him. Toney against B-Hop or Calzaghe is a pick em I'll admit but this gut is a Calzaghe hater. Not a B-Hop hater but not a B-Hop fan either. Why doesn't he mention Toney' loss to Griffin as well.

 

Toney
Hopkins





Calzaghe

Toney's best performances at middleweight clearly stand out above his 2 competitors. Hopkins's MW resume has a lot of depth, but his biggest wins came over a career welterweight and a former Featherweight, neither of who established a good resume at middleweight. De La Hoya and Trinidad both probably have about 3 quality middleweight wins between them. The Nunn KO was terrific, although I do think he was slightly overrated. The Kalambay win was odd, but an outstanding result nontheless. However, it is the fact that Nunn struggled with Iran Barkley and Marlon Starling that makes me question how good he actually was. Nunn's resume at the time wasn't exactly stellar.

I'm not even going to go into Calzaghe, I'm not quite sure why he's been included in this, Kessler and Lacy are decent wins, but neither were of the highest quality. To conclude, I think that both Nunn and Mcallum were very highly rated opponents, with good skills, who has at least established some sort of passable resume at the weight. The same can not be said for Hopkin's best opponents at MW.

 

Show me how Nunn was a top 10 p4p fighter then.

 

Not joking man - are you ******ed or something? :huh

Why can you not understand the difference between:

- a thread comparing the best performances of each fighter at a particular weight

and

- a thread comparing each man h2h across their careers

???


Why would I mention Toney's losses to Griffin, when they were at LIGHTHEAVYWEIGHT, and this thread is about Toney's BEST performances at MIDDLEWEIGHT?



And that's before we even get to the fact that you've been caught out talking ****ing **** about Kessler being in the top 10 just to suit your own argument, and also saying that a points win is more convincing than a ****ing knockout! atsch

It's people like you that make the General Forum a really tedious chore sometimes.

 

atschatschatsch

Blind as well as a ****ing halfwit then?

Look up.

In fact, I'll just quote my own post and simultaneously own you again:

 

Bull **** mate boxrec was not even around at that time, there rankings are not the best out there anyway.

 

You have to understand the thread starter. He hates Calzaghe with a passion, and has never forgiven him for beating Hopkins.

Now, he pretty much uses any angle he can to try to degrade Joe.

It's kinda sad, to waste your life on such a useless crusade. But hey, I can't make people smart just by wishing.

 

I've heard it all now. Look at my ****ing username you 12 year old moron!! :nut

Seriously, you cannot express ANY opinion on here without these gimps attributing it to some sort of pathetic agenda.

I'm logging out for a bit, this is just too depressing. :dead ****ing moron.

 

nut:nut

Can you read? Can you see the THREE fighters named in this thread????

**** this, I'm out of here. This place is becoming so pathetic I can't even stomach it anymore. Fanboy scum. :-(

 

It's funny as well, how the win against Nunn and the fights against McCallum were at middle but you say this means he has a better super middle resume.