Is Vitali Klitschko a ATG Heavyweight ?

I can see why people would consider Bowe the easiest fight for him of the four..... but on the flipside he could also be the hardest.

Lewis isn't the best inside fighter (nowhere near as good as Bowe) but he still banged Vitali up on the inside - Bowe has a good jab and excellent uppercut.

He (Klitschko) gets put through the ringer and is rescued by his corner in the mid-rounds :smoke

 

Wladimir rates more highly than Vitali simply because of the latter's "rest"...

Both break into top 30 of Heavyweights with Wladimir maybe pushing top 20.

 

No chance, H2H he doesn't score highly either.

 

Who are these people voting yes?atsch

 

No. Ultimately the only thing that can make you an all-time great fighter is achievement and record. H2H does come into it, but its a much smaller part as its far too subjective. It's like writing out a CV explaining how good you are without any grades or work experience.

He never was undisputed champion, he's never beaten other great fighters, he's not really even beaten good enough opponents consistently like his brother has.

 

haha these 2 klit clowns have been beating down young or veteran overweight bums for the last decade. not even good in this era just dominant in a **** bunch.

 

He's fought exactly one decent fighter and one very good one and he lost to them both. Do I really need to expound on this?

 

I respect the way he came back from injury and did what he did.
VERY awquard nights work for anyone, his style wasn't very pleasing on the eye, but he was effective.

I'll go with NO tho as he's a victim of the state of the division Had he been around in the divisions better days, who knows what he could've done, i certainly wouldn't be as dismissive as most.

 

No. Quality of opposition isn't good enough.

 

Can we atleast have some proper grammy in this thread. 'An ATG Champion.'

Also your list sucks balls, no Patterson or Schmeling yet you've got Earnie Shavers and Ron Lyle?

 

Bowe is an AWFUL matchup for both Klits, for reasons I have been over numerous times. Horrific matchup.

 

I agree.

 

:dealvitali beats bowe imho vitali bruatalizes him briggs spent twelve days in hospital:!:, one day for each round he did with vitali