Do you put Donaire above JMM on the P4p list?

Lol no, i have him at about 6. If he cleans up his division with Mares, Kameda, Agbeko, or Perez fights he'll rise.

 

I think JMM, John, Juan Lopez, klitchko vitali are higher.

 

JMM-3rd
Donaire-5th

IMO

 

No, but if/when he does become the undisputed bantamweight champ, then he should pass JMM on the list, depending of course what JMM does in his next fight and who he fights next.

 

Marquez is a veteran champion, Donaire has a lot to do to be able to challenge Marquez's status in the sport as one of the best P4P fighters ever to come out of Mexico....even if he drinks his own **** x_x

 

No... Nonito needs to fight and defeat more elite fighter in order to move ahead of JMM. He only has Darchinyan and Montiel on his resume.

 

3. Donaire
4. Martinez
5. JMM
6. W. Klitschko
7. Bradley
8. Ward
9. V. Klitschko
10a. Lopez
10b. Segura

 

Looked over his resume in detail lately.

In addition to his HOF caliber wins over Montiel and his KO and Upset of the Year over Darchinyan, he's got a resume.

Sidorenko and Mthalane are very legit wins. Everyone should know this.

Martinez and Maldonado are comparable with Sergio's wins over Bunema and Roman. In fact, I find them more impressive.

 

If you're going to put Donaire over Martinez, be prepared to lose all credibility you had atsch

 

Longevity and fighting the best year in year out you gotta give the nod to JMM. He deserves it. Donaire keeps beating top fighters in and around 122-126 then ok. You can make an argument for Donaire based on level of competition in the last couple fights are better than JMM but I gotta go with JMM guts, heart at this stage of his career is the difference.

 

1.pacquiao
2.Martinez
3.JMM
4. Donaire
5. Mayweather

 

yes I do. Donaire beat a better fighter than Marquez has beaten in years.

 

no...great, supppper great victory, but jmm is still above

if he stays active though, i can see him up there soon.....like in a year soon