Better Heavyweight Resumé: Adamek or Haye?

Marginal edge to Haye for Heavyweight resume:

Haye:

Old SNV
Old Barrett
Shot Ruiz
Bonin
Old Harrison

Adamek:

Obese Arreola
Old Grant
Maddalone
Estrada
Shot Golota

 

I dont agree on Bidenko. He put on great performance as for his fourth pro fight and also it was 12(!) rounder with much more experienced(Valuev was 28-0) and with physically much stronger boxer but still he lost it , I scored it or 115-113 for Valuev. And it was only 1 Valuev fight which you can watch without falling asleep.

 

I'm a Golota fan and I thought Andrew was going to beat Tomasz. However, I give credit where credit is due and I feel Adamek has the better resume and is the better fighter.

 

For crying out loud, senior citizen Holyfield fought even with Valuev! Barrett, Bonin and Harrison are complete crap! And shot Golota beat Ruiz!

Tomasz accomplished his HW resume in less than 12 months. Arreola might be chubby but he probably brings more to the table than Valuev.

 

Arreola has been matched brilliantly at heavyweight and his record flatters to deceive.

 

Haye would blow Adamek away easily, as would both Klitschko's.

The guy left his power at cruiserweight and will get put to sleep by any of the 3 above.

 

At least Adamek doesn't roll over for tilers.

If it took 3 rounds for Haye to put Harrison to sleep how's he going to put Adamek to sleep in 3? Harrison might as well have had his hands tied behind his back. atsch

 

yeah but it only takes SMW power to put Haye on his ass!

 

****ing Canadians...

At least Jorodz ok... he's one of the good ones...

 

Just pathetic.

Haye, not even close. Adamek's only fought one guy of note, Arreola. Valuev and Ruiz might not be ATGs, but they were at the top of the division bar the Klitchkos.

 

i think haye. i just like arreola on adameks resume.

haye fought valuev and ruiz at least

 

What are you smoking son? You cannot just look at names and boxrec. You've got to see the performance and know the quality of the fighter at the time the fight took place. Haye barely managed to eek out a victory over one of the biggest pretenders to hold a championship belt ever. Ruiz was way past it when Haye faced him. This isn't even a point of contention. Everyone knows Ruiz was old and no longer had the energy to carry on his hugging routine. As for the CW, ask yourself one question - has Haye beaten anyone who is of any relevence today as a CW? Please answer that.

 

These are just names. For starters, do remember that Haye barely beat Valuev in one of the most boring fights in ages and Ruiz was an old past it fighter. Arreola on the other hand was in his prime. To me even though Valuev has done more than Arreola, Valuev did so taking the easier route. f2f, Arreola would win over Valuev and would probably get robbed in the process just like Holyfield and Donald.

 

lol, as opposed to Valuev?

 

Basically its going to Germany and outboxing Valuev or winning a brawl/boxing match against Arreola in US.

My vote goes to the Valuev win, hence Haye has the better heavyweight resume.